Work

A 'Hierarchy of Justice': The Impact of Western Definitions of UK Image-Based Abuse Legislation

Year: 2026
Type: conference-paper
Abstract: Image-based abuse is predominantly criminalised in England and Wales under section 66B of the Sexual Offences Act (2003). Within the act, certain image-based abuse offences are described as ‘sharing or threatening to share intimate photograph or film’, but what does intimate mean? Further defined in the act, ‘intimate’ is described as (a) the person participating or engaging in an act which a reasonable person would consider to be a sexual act, (b) the person doing a thing which a reasonable person would consider to be sexual, (c) all or part of the person’s exposed genitals, buttocks or breasts, (d) the person in an act of urination or defecation, or (e) the person carrying out an act of personal care associated with the person’s urination, defecation or genital or anal discharge. The latter terms are especially clinical and wholly tied to nudity or sexual acts – a confined view of ‘intimate’. Here legal definitions developed from Western heteronormative standards fall short of what many women and people experience as intimacy. Individuals, particularly those most marginalised, who experience threats to, or the sharing of non-consensual content find themselves unprotected by England and Wales legislation, as the context of their abuse may fall outside of these reductive parameters (Dhir, 2026; Kolisetty, 2021). At times, marginalised people seeking justice are recommended to use alternative routes, such as harassment offences. However, these are neither reflective of the abuse experienced, nor responded to as urgently (Dhir, 2026). Consequently, this creates a ‘hierarchy of justice’ (Dhir, 2026). This abstract will explore CWPO researchers Alishya Dhir and Leyla Buran’s work to address these considerable legal gaps. Including, a critical reflection of the process of amending legislation, and the symbolism of attempting to improve a system which, within its foundations, has been shaped by and for the West.
Institution: The Open University
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204492102
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10