Governance without Consequence: A Forensic Analysis of Systemic Control Failures and Accountability Gaps in Ghanaian Institutions
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Ghana has, over the past two decades, enacted an extensive body of legislation designed to strengthen institutional accountability, improve public financial management, and deter corrupt conduct in both public and private sectors. However, the country continues to register persistent, well-documented failures of governance at every level of its institutional architecture, from state-owned enterprises to financial regulatory bodies to district assemblies. This paper examines the structural and systemic reasons why formal governance arrangements in Ghana so frequently fail to produce the accountability outcomes they were designed to achieve. Drawing on forensic accounting theory, institutional theory, and principal-agent analysis, and engaging closely with the evidentiary record from Ghana's Public Accounts Committee reports, Auditor-General findings, CHRAJ investigations, and the judicial record, the paper argues that Ghana confronts not merely a problem of weak enforcement but a deeper problem of consequence-free governance, a condition in which institutional actors are routinely able to violate control systems, divert public resources, and frustrate oversight mechanisms without incurring proportionate consequences. The paper traces this condition to four interacting pathogenic mechanisms: the fragmentation of accountability architecture across constitutionally mandated bodies that lack both coordination and coercive power; the capture of audit and oversight institutions by political and executive interests; the juridification trap, in which legal processes designed to enforce accountability are so protracted and resource-intensive that they effectively neutralize deterrence; and the normalization of impunity, whereby repeated no prosecution of established governance breaches erodes institutional legitimacy and signals to actors at all levels that consequences are negotiable. The paper concludes with a forensic governance reform agenda that directly addresses these mechanisms, including proposals for a unified accountability enforcement commission, mandatory surcharge recovery mechanisms, and a forensic audit reserve fund under the Auditor-General's Office. The findings carry implications beyond Ghana for any jurisdiction in which formal governance architecture coexists with systemic accountability failure.
Author: Godwin Gaduga
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7204497274
