Work

Decolonising child protection (and why we don’t have to call it that)

Year: 2026
Type: conference-paper
Abstract: This presentation focuses on decolonising the child protection system in Aotearoa New Zealand, where tamariki Māori (Indigenous children) remain over-represented. It draws on a recent study which built on the researcher’s PhD thesis on the same topic. While that research focused on why decolonising the child protection system was necessary, this research examined why decolonisation is possible. The objectives of the study were three-fold: 1. To illustrate examples where potential steps towards decolonisation are already underway (for example, where child protection services are currently provided by Māori service providers in partnership with the State). 2. To examine whether examples of Indigenous child protection frameworks overseas could be adapted to an Aotearoa New Zealand context effectively. 3. To determine what legislative changes might be needed to affect the shift towards a decolonised child protection system. Two primary methods were used, in line with the above objectives. Part one of the research involved qualitative case study research examining the already-underway work of three iwi-based (tribal) social services, while part two involved theoretical research examining recent developments overseas, namely the passage of Bill C-92 in Canada, and the upholding of ICWA in the US Supreme Court. Six themes were identified from the empirical aspects of the work: 1. Longevity and resilience – the commitment of iwi-based organisations to the safety of tamariki Māori dates back far longer than any given legislative change. 2. Tikanga – these groups all anchored their work in Māori concepts, values and practices. 3. Mana motuhake – all three organisations were working explicitly, and strategically, towards a future in which Māori self-determination (mana motuhake) is achieved. 4. Frustration and pragmatism – working with the State has been time consuming, inequitable and frustrating, but there have still been glimmers of hope. 5. Effectiveness and leadership – these organisations were able to demonstrate their effectiveness when enabling legislation was in place, despite the inadequacy of that legislation. 6. Kupu māori – there may be terms other than ‘decolonisation’ which resonate more strongly for those doing this work in describing what they do. Three further themes were identified from the comparative aspects of the work: 1. The importance of explicitly recognising Indigenous sovereignty. 2. The impact of public inquiries, awareness and accountability. 3. The value of stand-alone Indigenous child protection legislation. This research concludes that decolonising the child protection system remains both necessary and possible in Aotearoa New Zealand, but also that we might not need to label it that if there are other ways to label these changes which resonate more in this country. Key takeaways for the audience of this presentation may include: • Decolonisation of the child protection system remains necessary, and must involve challenging the state’s assumed authority to remove Māori children from their families. • Decolonisation of the child protection system is also possible, due to both work already underway in Aotearoa New Zealand and examples of decolonisation overseas. • Law and policy reform must be grounded in explicit recognition of Māori tino rangatiratanga and mana motuhake (self-determination). • These findings may have broader implications for other Indigenous peoples globally.
Language: English
Subfield: Health
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7204697479
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10