The Right to Be Heard and Broad Defense in Algorithmic Content Moderation: The Duty of Care in STF Themes 987 and 533 as a Minimum Standard of Digital Due Process
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: When an algorithm restricts a user’s content, no procedural guarantee governs what the platform owes that user. Opacity and power asymmetry turn automated moderation into a materially jurisdictional function exercised without justification or contestation. This article asks whether the right to be heard and broad defense (Article 5, LV, of the Brazilian Constitution) bind large-scale platforms by direct horizontal effect. Combining a literature review on digital constitutionalism with documental analysis of RE 1.037.396/SP and RE 1.057.258/MG against the European Digital Services Act, it finds that the thesis fixed jointly in Themes 987 and 533 parameterized procedural duties only toward the public, while item 5.5 leaves the moderated user a judicial remedy under a reversed burden of proof and no indemnity, in a ruling premised on the slowness of judicial protection. The article proposes a minimum standard of digital due process: transparency, reasoned notification, accessible human review, and safety by design.
Source: Sapientia Iuris
Institution: Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte
Language: English
Topic: Brazilian Legal Issues
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7208870090
