Addressing the proliferation of incompetent leaders: The imperative role of improving follower status and stability
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: It is estimated that nearly half of all managers will fail to meet organizational objectives due to lacking skills and traits necessary for the role (Hogan et al., 2010).Possible reasons for the proliferation of incompetent leaders could be related to poor selection decisions and a lack of guidance for addressing competence issues.Indeed, Ducheyne and De Fruyt (2026) assert that organizations should consider motivation and competence in leader selection processes, and the authors offer solutions rooted in development and training.We agree that it is imperative to select the people who both want and can lead others.However, given that incompetent leadership is so widespread, it is fruitful to take a few steps back and reflect on why people who lack the necessary motivation or competencies consider and accept leadership roles.We bring attention to social tendencies of prioritizing leadership, in which society has elevated the importance of leaders over followers.This is evident as leaders are rewarded with better pay, respect, and stability compared to followers.Given that most people are worried about money, work, and the economy (American Psychological Association, 2025b), workers may strive to advance their career by attaining leadership positions-even if that does not align with their interests or skills.A potential answer to this issue lies in the need to uplift the role of being "just a follower."Organizations can do this by promoting systems that emphasize followership principles, 1 using equity theory to support followers and their contributions, and offering mechanisms for advancement that do not push people into managerial roles.
Institution: University of Maryland, College Park
Language: English
Subfield: Strategy and Management
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $3,550
OpenAlex ID: W7212290262
