Divine Revelation or Human Origin? An Epistemological, Historical, and Bayesian Analysis of the Qur'an (2nd ed.).
Year: 2026
Type: book
Abstract: Divine Revelation or Human Origin? is a critical study of the Qur’an’s origins through the lens of Bayesian reasoning, historical analysis, and inference to the best explanation. Rather than beginning from either faith or skepticism, the book asks a narrower question: given the evidence available to us, what can actually be established about whether the Qur’an is best explained by genuine divine revelation or by ordinary human and historical processes? The investigation compares competing revelation and human-origin models across a wide range of evidence, including the Qur’an’s Late Antique context, religious geography and diversity, cognition and religious belief, Adam and human evolution, the Flood, alleged textual and legal difficulties, literary inimitability, prophecy, miracle traditions, scientific-miracle claims, textual preservation, Egyptian historical knowledge, and the transmission of hadith. Throughout, the book distinguishes possibility from probability, compatibility from confirmation, undercutting from counterevidence, and local evidential judgments from global conclusions. It also examines how source uncertainty, dependence between arguments, retrospective selection, model flexibility, and differing theological commitments affect the strength of common apologetic and skeptical arguments. The result is deliberately restrained. The analysis finds that some popular arguments for revelation are substantially weaker than often claimed, while several skeptical objections also fail to establish what they are sometimes taken to prove. A number of arguments retain genuine conditional evidential force in either direction, but the study does not establish a defensible overall Bayesian ranking between divine revelation and human origin. The final chapter also develops an epistemic ḥujjah problem, asking what follows if a competent, adequately informed and nonresistant investigator can remain rationally uncertain about Muhammad’s prophetic authority, and how this bears on claims about divine authentication, culpability, and religious responsibility. Written for readers interested in philosophy of religion, Qur’anic studies, historical method, and comparative epistemology, Divine Revelation or Human Origin? is not an attempt to replace scholarship with probability language, nor to disguise theological assumptions as mathematics. Its aim is to identify exactly where the evidence discriminates between competing explanations, where it does not, and what further work would be required to justify a stronger conclusion.
Author: S., Betim
Language: English
Subfield: Religious studies
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: Quran, revelation, Bayesian reasoning, inference to the best explanation, epistemic uncertainty, apologetics, skepticism, prophetic authority, hadith transmission, flood narrative, scientific miracles, textual preservation, religious geography, religious diversity, religious cognition, religious responsibility
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7212445153
