Work

Comparative durability performance of conventional and next-generation SCM-modified concrete: Chloride transport, carbonation, corrosion, ASR, and thermal properties

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: With the increasing use of supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs), understanding the durability performance of SCM-modified concrete, particularly emerging SCMs, has become important. Existing reviews evaluate SCMs individually or focus on specific deterioration mechanisms, leaving the comparative analysis between conventional and emerging SCMs across multiple durability mechanisms. In particular, there is limited data on the effect of SCM type and replacement level on chloride ingress, carbonation, corrosion, ASR, and thermal conductivity, and their implications for long-term performance. This article, therefore, establishes a comparative framework that integrates performance, governing mechanisms, replacement levels, and service-life implications across conventional and emerging SCMs. Across the studies, 20% replacement is frequently investigated in ASR, corrosion, and thermal-conductivity-focused studies, while 30% replacement is often considered for chloride-transport and carbonation evaluation, with binary blends dominating and ternary systems less frequently studied but promising in calcined-clay-based mixtures. SCM incorporation generally improves chloride transport resistance, corrosion performance, and ASR mitigation, whereas carbonation resistance often deteriorates at higher replacement levels and thermal conductivity remains mixture dependent. Conventional SCMs show more consistent trends across studies, while emerging SCMs are supported by fewer studies and exhibit greater variability. Durability improvements are mainly linked to pore refinement, reduced pore connectivity and physical and chemical binding, while carbonation deterioration is mostly associated with clinker dilution and reduced alkaline buffering. Conventional SCM blends can provide up to seven times longer service life than pure OPC under chloride exposure by delaying corrosion initiation, and limited evidence suggests calcined clay ternary blends can meet coastal design life targets.
Language: English
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $1,540
OpenAlex ID: W7213596299
FWCI:
Cites: 262
Cited by:
Related to: 10