Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The concept of “post-truth” has gained popularity as a way to characterize Western political culture since the emergence of the Make America Great Again (MAGA) movement in the United States. Alongside the public recognition of this term is a wider assumption that political audiences, especially those who support the policies of Donald Trump are rejecting therole of fact in the deliberative process. I suggest that this is a mischaracterization of how audiences interact with rhetoric. Audiences are always involved in mediating their understanding of the world through subjective experiences. Therefore, the positions termed reasonable or rational do not possess privileged access to objective reality but are assigned these labels as part of broader systems of power. I argue that conventional understandings of post-truth that suggest epistemic superiority serve to engender demagogic divisions by characterizing groups as irrational. I support this claim by demonstrating how the acceptance of typical post-truth rhetoric does not necessarily rely on a rejection of truth, but the overreliance on epistemic objectivity that transgresses into naïve realism. This problem is also understood as being more than just a symptom exhibited among the American right-wing. Critics of the MAGA movement are equally susceptible to the same kinds of epistemic naivety that engender post-truth conditions among the right. The first section of this dissertation argues for the redefinition of post-truth as a product of naïve realism and the application of a rhetorical epistemology as a means of responding to post-truth conditions. The second section moves through three sites where truth is expected to inform action: politics, science, and education. I explain how within these sites an epistemically naïve position yields ineffective results and instead requires methods of negotiating complicated rhetorical situations. Rhetoric is understood here as more than just a method of making truth more palatable, but a component of constructing reality as a site where multiple actors can come together and respond to the material exigencies the community acknowledges as being true.
Source: Lehigh Preserve
Author: Christopher Shosted
Institution: Lehigh University
Language: English
Subfield: Communication
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7214138367
