Work

When is a “Compaff” a “Compass”? Navigating Credit Assignment for Perceptual Learning and Word Learning in Speech

Year: 2026
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In everyday life, listeners frequently encounter situations where spoken language is ambiguous or unfamiliar: words can be drowned out by background noise, talkers may speak in unfamiliar accents, and sound sequences can correspond to unknown words. Although each of these scenarios presents unique challenges to speech comprehension, listeners nonetheless succeed at inferring a talker’s intended meaning most of the time. This success is contingent upon the application of the appropriate form of learning for that particular context (e.g., perceptual learning for accented speech, word learning for unfamiliar sound sequences). Despite extensive research on the individual forms of learning that enable fluid comprehension of unfamiliar speech, relatively little is known about how listeners cope with situations where multiple forms of learning may be relevant. The goal of the present thesis is therefore to demonstrate that the challenge of adjudicating between competing forms of learning, known as the credit assignment problem, is central to speech comprehension and is a tractable topic of study. We do so through the direct comparison of two forms of learning, perceptual learning and word learning, using an experimental paradigm that enables both to emerge in a single task. In Chapter 1, we introduce a novel framework for understanding forms of learning in language as processes of adaptation and acquisition at multiple levels of linguistic processing, juxtaposing topics typically studied in isolation and emphasising the importance of credit assignment. Chapter 2 includes results from two behavioural studies involving a novel experimental design that uses predictive sentence contexts to enable either perceptual learning or word learning on a trial-by-trial basis. Study 1 demonstrates that both forms of learning can be elicited by this procedure but are differentially affected by manipulations of type and token frequency during training. An optimised study design implemented in Study 2 enables the emergence of both perceptual learning and word learning that persist for at least 12 hours. Group differences from Study 1—combined with Bayesian correlation results from Study 2—demonstrate that perceptual learning and word learning are behaviourally dissociable processes with dissociable underlying mechanisms. Chapter 3 presents results from three behavioural studies and a meta-analysis. These were conducted to assess the robustness of the experimental paradigm used in Chapter 2 and to adapt it for use in magnetoencephalography (MEG). Results emphasise the success of listeners at determining which form of learning to apply, based on surrounding semantic context, even when identical spoken items occur in perceptual learning contexts for some participants and word learning contexts for others. Chapter 4 reports an MEG study using the optimised paradigm from Chapter 3. The results illustrate further behavioural dissociations between perceptual learning and word learning, in addition to novel neural dissociations indicative of encoding processes during word learning and rapid adaptation in the left temporal cortex during perceptual learning. Counterbalancing of stimuli between learning conditions in a single task enabled the specific attribution of differences to learning, rather than inter-stimulus or inter-task variability, thus demonstrating a central strength of the experimental paradigm developed in this thesis. In Chapter 5, we synthesise these findings and suggest that emphasising the credit assignment problem provides new perspectives on challenges faced in the context of non-native language learning, developmental language disorder, and automated speech recognition systems. In sum, the present thesis reframes the understudied problem of credit assignment as tractable and critical to speech comprehension and demonstrates, through six empirical studies, that directly comparing forms of learning typically studied in isolation can advance our understanding of how listeners accommodate unfamiliar speech.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7214215340
Cites: 300
Cited by:
Related to: 8