Integrating Molecular Diagnostics and Vector Surveillance for Early Detection of Arboviral Threats in Temperate and Tropical Settings
Year: 2024
Type: article
Abstract: Arboviral early detection depends on two data streams that are usually generated, analysed and governed separately. Molecular diagnostics operate on human specimens, within clinical laboratories, under clinical accreditation regimes, and answer the question of whether a presenting patient is infected. Vector surveillance operates on arthropod collections, within entomology or vector control programmes, under no comparable accreditation regime, and answers the question of whether transmission is occurring in a defined area. Because the arboviral transmission cycle runs through the vector before it reaches the patient, the entomological stream is in principle the leading indicator and the clinical stream the lagging one — yet in practice the clinical stream is the better resourced, the better standardised and the one that triggers response. This review examines what integration of the two would require, and what the evidence says about the performance of each component. It covers the diagnostic architecture of arboviral laboratory confirmation and its constraints, including the viraemic window that limits molecular testing to roughly the first five days of illness and the flavivirus serological cross-reactivity that limits confirmation thereafter; multiplex real-time reverse-transcription PCR and the sensitivity penalty multiplexing imposes; isothermal amplification and CRISPR-based platforms as candidate field-deployable technologies; sequencing and genomic epidemiology as operational rather than research activities; vector trapping methods and the weak evidence base for entomological threshold indices; molecular xenomonitoring and the statistical treatment of pooled infection-rate estimation; and novel modalities including mosquito excreta capture, environmental DNA and wastewater detection. The contrast between temperate and tropical surveillance regimes is treated as structural rather than incidental: a region reporting millions of dengue cases with partial laboratory confirmation faces a different integration problem from one reporting a few hundred West Nile virus cases and relying on animal and vector sentinels for sensitivity. The review concludes that the principal obstacles to integration are not analytical but institutional — differences in accreditation, data standards, turnaround expectations and workforce credentialling between the clinical and entomological arms — and identifies the specific standards, quality systems and workforce investments that would close them.
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7214925151
