ضوابط رخصة الشرع للمرور بمزدلفة دراسة مقارنة فقهية: Legal Parameters Of The Shariah Concession For Passing Through Muzdalifah: A Comparative Fiqh Study
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This study presents a comparative jurisprudential analysis of the Shariah-based concession (rukhsah) allowing pilgrims to pass through Muzdalifah without spending the night there—an emerging contemporary issue that calls for further legal grounding, due to the increasing number of legitimate excuses, diverse fatwas, and the complexity of modern Hajj logistics. The study aims to clarify the Shariah ruling on overnight stay (mabīt) in Muzdalifah, and to establish principled criteria for applying this rukhsah by examining the relevant legal evidences and the views of the four major Sunni schools of jurisprudence. This study contributes to the contemporary juristic framework of Shariah concessions in Hajj by establishing legal criteria within the context of fiqh al-nawāzil and the objectives of Islamic law. It further investigates the minimum time required to fulfill the overnight stay obligation and identifies the earliest permissible time for the excused—such as the elderly, women, and the weak—to depart from Muzdalifah. The researcher adopted an inductive approach to trace scriptural and juristic details, alongside a comparative method to present, contrast, and evaluate the differing opinions based on textual proofs and the objectives of Islamic law (maqāṣid al-sharīʿah). Among the study’s key findings is that jurists differed on the legal status of mabīt in Muzdalifah: some considered it a pillar (rukn), others a wajib act, and others a sunnah; the researcher favored the opinion that it is wajib and that failure to perform it without excuse requires a compensatory sacrifice. Jurists also disagreed on the minimum duration required for mabīt, presenting four views: staying until after Fajr, after moonset, after midnight, or brief presence only; the preferred view holds that staying after midnight suffices. Regarding the departure time for those with valid excuses, three opinions were identified: after midnight (the majority view), after moonset, or at any point during the night after arrival; the study concludes that the first view is strongest, though delaying until moonset is preferable. Ultimately, the study concludes that the proper application of this concession is governed by two essential conditions: (1) the presence of a valid Shariah-recognized excuse and (2) that departure occurs after midnight, thereby balancing textual evidence, majority opinion, and the higher aims of Shariah in facilitating ease and maintaining legal discipline.
Source: AL-FIKRAH Jurnal Kajian Islam
Authors: Muhammad Ridwan, Muhammad Ikhsan, Sirajuddin
Institution: Institut Agama Islam STIBA Makassar
Language: English
Subfield: Religious studies
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7215701005
