Work

Comparative Evaluation of ACI, BRE-DOE, and IS Mix Design Methods for Grade 20 Recycled Aggregate Concrete

Year: 2024
Type: article
Abstract: This study evaluated the suitability of three concrete mix design methods, namely the American Concrete Institute (ACI), the British Department of Environment (BRE-DOE), and the Indian Standard (IS) methods, for producing grade 20 concrete containing recycled concrete aggregate (RCA). The aim was to identify the most appropriate mix design approach for achieving a satisfactory balance between workability and mechanical performance when recycled coarse aggregate is incorporated into concrete. A comparative laboratory experiment was carried out using Portland limestone cement, river sand, crushed granite, recycled concrete aggregate derived from waste concrete, and potable water. Concrete mixes were proportioned using the absolute volume method and assessed through slump, compressive strength, and split tensile strength tests. Standard cube and cylindrical specimens were cast and cured under water before testing. The results showed that all three methods produced workable concrete and achieved compressive strengths above the target grade at 28 days. The BRE-DOE mix recorded the highest slump of 75 mm, followed by the ACI mix at 67 mm, while the IS mix gave the lowest slump of 46 mm. In terms of compressive strength, the ACI mix produced the highest values throughout the curing period, reaching 25.34 N/mm2 at 28 days, compared with 22.67 N/mm2 for BRE-DOE and 21.56 N/mm2 for IS. A similar pattern was observed for split tensile strength, where the ACI mix attained the highest 28-day value of 3.54 N/mm2, followed by BRE-DOE at 3.25 N/mm2 and IS at 2.97 N/mm2. These findings show that, although the BRE-DOE method provided superior workability, the ACI method offered the best overall balance of fresh and hardened concrete performance. The study therefore concludes that the ACI method is the most suitable of the three for grade 20 recycled aggregate concrete under the conditions investigated
Language: English
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7220133824
FWCI:
Cites: 8
Cited by:
Related to: 10