Work

The Efficiency of Enforcement of Court Judgments and the Protection of the Rights of Participants in Enforcement Proceedings as Interrelated Guarantees of the Right to a Fair Trial: A Constitutional and Comparative Legal Analysis

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: The article provides a constitutional and comparative legal analysis of the interrelationship between the efficiency of enforcement of court judgments and the proper protection of the rights of participants in enforcement proceedings as two mutually reinforcing guarantees of the right to a fair trial. The starting premise is that a court judgment acquires its full rights-protective value only if it is actually enforced; accordingly, the enforcement stage is a functionally necessary continuation of the administration of justice. It is argued that Article 129-1 of the Constitution of Ukraine establishes a tripartite framework: the binding nature of a court decision, the State's positive obligation to secure its enforcement, and judicial oversight as both a safeguard against arbitrariness and an instrument of procedural justice (certitudo iuris; summum ius, summa iniuria). The methodological foundation of the study combines dialectical and systemic approaches, doctrinal analysis, the comparative method, and synthesis of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights and the Constitutional Court of Ukraine. The article elucidates Convention standards on enforcement as an integral component of Article 6 of the ECHR (including precedents addressing the structural problem of non-enforcement in Ukraine), as well as relevant Council of Europe instruments (Rec(2003)17, CEPEJ Guidelines 2009/2015, CCJE Opinion No. 13), which require the simultaneous attainment of effective enforcement and proportionality of interference with the rights of the debtor and third parties. On this basis, the article formulates a theoretical and legal model of effectiveness under which measures of enforcement must be swift and effective, yet procedurally fair, foreseeable, and subject to judicial control. It proposes benchmarks for implementing European approaches in Ukraine: strengthening judicial oversight without creating excessive access barriers; ensuring transparency and legal certainty of procedures; maintaining proportionality of measures and safeguarding the debtor's minimum means of subsistence; enabling effective asset tracing with robust personal data protection guarantees; rationalizing enforcement costs; and preventing abuses that operate as a tactic for delaying enforcement proceedings.
Author: Olha Verba
Language: Ukrainian
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7220847996
FWCI: 18.02
Cites: 4
Cited by: 3
Related to: 9