Work

Comparison of the Accuracy of the Tooth Coronal Index Benindra and the Kvaal Method for Estimating Adult Age Using Panoramic Radiographs

Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Background: Dental age estimation plays an important role in forensic identification and legal assessments of living individuals. In adults, estimation commonly relies on age-related secondary dentin deposition, which reduces pulp cavity dimensions. The Tooth Coronal Index (TCI) Benindra and Kvaal methods assess these changes using different radiographic measurements. This study compared the accuracy of these methods for adult dental age estimation using digital panoramic radiographs. Purpose: This study aimed to analyze the accuracy of the TCI Benindra and Kvaal methods for adult age estimation using panoramic radiographs. Methods: This cross-sectional design used 100 panoramic radiographs. We analyzed the data using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences software, including a Wilcoxon signed-rank test, and assessed accuracy using mean absolute error (MAE). Results: TCI Benindra significantly underestimated age across all three teeth, with mean differences of −4.59 ± 5.35, −7.32 ± 6.18, and −8.24 ± 6.46 years, respectively (all p < 0.001). Kvaal also underestimated age for the maxillary second premolar (−2.39 ± 7.89 years; p = 0.003), but overestimated age for the mandibular canine (8.94 ± 6.94 years) and first premolar (3.45 ± 8.95 years) (both p < 0.001). TCI Benindra demonstrated significantly lower MAE than Kvaal for the maxillary second premolar (5.29 vs. 6.70 years; p = 0.008) and mandibular canine (7.47 vs. 9.94 years; p = 0.014). For the mandibular first premolar, Kvaal showed a lower MAE, although the difference was not statistically significant. Conclusion: The accuracy of adult dental age estimation varied by method and tooth examined. TCI Benindra performed better for the maxillary second premolar and mandibular canine, whereas Kvaal showed a numerical advantage for the mandibular first premolar. Neither method performed consistently better across all tooth types.
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7225462016
FWCI:
Cites: 18
Cited by:
Related to: 10