Work

“Enchanting Jumble”: The Politics of Imperfection in Rose Macaulay’s What Not

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This article presents an analysis of Rose Macaulay’s 1919 novel What Not. The novel portrays various characters’ experiences and interactions in a post-war Britain in which the “Ministry of Brains” is endeavouring to implement eugenics to improve the general intelligence of the population—and so reduce the chances of a recurrence of war. Following a description of the novel, I contextualise the version of eugenics that it satirises and comment on the connection between eugenics and modernism. The novel, through its comic irony, presents, I argue, a cogent critique of social engineering. I make this point by juxtaposing What Not with the Platonic utopias of H. G. Wells. Macaulay’s liberalism, I suggest, is “a politics of imperfection,” a celebration of what she terms “the enchanting jumble,” which stands as a counterpoint to planned, closed societies.
Source: Scrutiny2
Language: English
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7225908907
FWCI:
Cites: 10
Cited by:
Related to: 10