Work

Protocol for the transdisciplinary synthesis of a large-scale primary healthcare research program: Integrating the Double Diamond framework with Realist Evaluation and Ripple Effects Mapping

Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Study Protocol
Abstract: Primary healthcare is increasingly prioritized to address healthcare challenges associated with population aging, multimorbidity, workforce shortages, and care fragmentation. While a growing body of evidence describes primary healthcare reform strategies and their outcomes, less is known about the mechanisms through which these strategies operate across different system levels and contexts. Existing evaluation approaches often assume linear causality and stable interventions, limiting their ability to explain complex, adaptive change processes. Consequently, methodological approaches that systematically examine mechanisms, context, and multi-level dynamics in primary healthcare are lacking. In this study, we address the current lack of mechanism-oriented and context-sensitive research on primary healthcare. We describe a methodology to examine which mechanisms influence primary healthcare systems in transition, trying to explain for whom, under which conditions, how, and why these mechanisms contribute to intended and unintended outputs, outcomes, and impacts of primary healthcare reforms. We describe a protocol for an iterative, interdisciplinary, participatory mixed-methods design structured within the Double Diamond framework. We integrate Realist Evaluation and Ripple Effects Mapping to capture complexity, context, and multi-level change processes over time. Through iterative cycles of inquiry, reflection, and synthesis, the approach supports the development of a comprehensive understanding of transition processes in complex adaptive systems. This protocol contributes to the methodological literature on evaluating transitions in complex adaptive systems by explicitly incorporating mechanisms, contextual conditions, and system dynamics. The findings are expected to inform future research as well as policy and practice aimed at strengthening the primary healthcare systems.
Source: PLoS ONE
Language: English
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,382
OpenAlex ID: W7233992123
FWCI:
Cites: 39
Cited by:
Related to: 10
Parts: 4