Patient and Provider Perception, Assessment and Treatment of Pain in Pre-Hospital Emergency Care: A Scoping Review of Direct, Related and Indirect Evidence
Year: 2026
Type: article
Study design: Systematic Review
Abstract: Background and Objectives: Acute pain is among the most frequent reasons for pre-hospital emergency contact, yet how accurately it is perceived and how adequately it is treated remains poorly understood. Analgesic decisions rest on the clinician’s assessment, so a patient–provider difference in perceived pain may affect treatment. This scoping review mapped the evidence on patient and provider perception, assessment and treatment of pre-hospital pain, separating direct evidence (patient and provider ratings of the same pain) from related and indirect evidence. Materials and Methods: The review followed the Joanna Briggs Institute 2020 methodology and the PRISMA-ScR checklist, with a pre-registered protocol. Three databases and three grey literature sources were searched with a perception-focused strategy, backward citation tracking and screening by two reviewers. Each study was appraised with a design-matched tool and explicit rating rules, and treatment findings were charted with their denominators and outcome definitions. Results: Sixty studies from 20 countries (2003–2025) were included. Of the 52 with patient samples, 19 were restricted to adults, 13 demonstrated adult predominance, 19 had uncertain age composition, and one held no age data. Only two studies compared patient and provider ratings in real patients, and in both, providers rated pain lower. The difference was small on average (4.2 versus 3.6 on a 0–10 scale in patients with pain) and larger in severe pain, possibly reflecting regression to the mean. Five further studies gave related evidence. Low documented analgesic use was common, but its rate depended on the denominator, and few studies recorded refusal, contraindications or previous medication. Where studies defined undertreatment themselves, it was frequent. Pain documentation and reassessment were often incomplete. Conclusions: Paired clinical evidence on the perception gap is limited, and documentation and treatment practices vary substantially. The contribution of rating disagreement to treatment decisions remains unestablished.
Source: Medicina
Language: English
Subfield: Emergency Medicine
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,654
OpenAlex ID: W7234114709
