Year: 2002
Type: article
Abstract: The phrase "privacy law" is admittedly amorphous, and might be understood to refer to any number of discrete bodies of American law, including the constitutional "right to privacy" reflected in such substantive due process decisions as those protecting personal decisions of issues relating to reproduction and procreation.See, e.g., Griswold v. Connecticut, 381 U.S. 479 (1965) (recognizing privacy right relating to procreation and use of 1 Smolla: Accounting for the Slow Growth of American Privacy Law Published by NSUWorks, 2002 Nova Law ReviewIt has been a consistently poor achiever, barely keeping up with inflation.I speak here of privacy law in the tort sense, and the four torts that are classically understood to comprise invasion of privacy: 1) false light; 2) 2 publication of private facts; 3) intrusion; and 4) appropriation.Of these four torts, only appropriation (or "the right of publicity") has been a ripping success for plaintiffs, a genuine high-return stock, and a species of intellectual property, even though appropriation is arguably not a true form of invasion of privacy at all. 3 Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis are frequently credited for having launched modern privacy law in their article The Right to Privacy. 4 Warren and Brandeis have been critiqued by such estimable scholars as Diane Zimmerman and Harry Kalven, Jr., who have played the requiem for the tort, asking if Warren and Brandeis were wrong.I come not to bury privacy, however, but to praise it, and lament its stunted growth.The ambition of this article is to try to account for the generally anemic performance of privacy law, and in the process to suggest a number of palliatives that might modestly rejuvenate it. II. ACCOUNTING FOR THE WEAKNESS OF THE FIRST THREE PRIVACY TORTSConsider these weaknesses in the first three privacy torts: 1) false light; 2) publication of private facts; and 3) intrusion.First, false light is not much contraceptives); Planned Parenthood v. Casey, 505 U.S. 833 (1992) (affirming "core" of abortion right recognized in Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973), but modifying that right through imposition of "undue burden" standard).In this article, I use the term exclusively to refer to tort law causes of action that purport to protect privacy.2. William L. Prosser, Privacy, 48 CAL.L. REV.383, 389 (1960).This four-part taxonomy of privacy law was originally ordained by the tort oracle William Prosser, who first labored to bring structure to privacy law by creating these four categories.3. See infra notes 150-51 and accompanying text.Throughout this article, I frequently engage in a kind of legal anthropomorphizing-that is, I treat the "law of privacy" or the cause of action for "false light" or the "law of defamation" as if it were human, with ambition for "success."Of course this is a fiction, and I employ it merely as an economical and vivid narrative device.4.
Source: Nova law review
Author: Rodney A. Smolla
Language: English
Topic: Law, Rights, and Freedoms
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7286941
