Fishing in the Bering Sea Donut: Straddling Stocks and the New International Law of Fisheries
Year: 1989
Type: article
Abstract: THE WORLD 251 (1985).2. Articles 56, 61, and 62 of the 1982 Convention on the Law of the Sea, considered by many to reflect customary international law, grant coastal states sovereign rights for use and management of living resources, including conservation, within a 200 nautical mile Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ).See United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, Dec. 10, 1982, arts.61, 62, U.N. Doc.A/CONF.62/122,21 I.L.M. 1261, 1281 [hereinafter 1982 Convention].Most states believe these rights are extensive and that there are few limits on coastal state authority.The significant choices of the coastal state in management are discretionary and cannot be challenged in a compulsory dispute settlement proceeding that is otherwise applicable.1982 Convention, supra, art.297(3)(a).See generally G. MOORE, COASTAL STATE REQUIREMENTS FOR FOREIGN FISHING 6-10 (U.N.Food and Agriculture Organization Legislative Study No. 21, 2d rev.ed.1985) (brief overview of various coastal states' duty to allow access to surplus catch).This conception of coastal state authority over EEZ fisheries is not universal.There is a body of opinion that a coastal state is required by international law to give foreign access to an EEZ fishery if the coastal state cannot or will not harvest the biologically safe annual yield.Such an interpretation of customary law would restrict, if not deny, a right to regulate the fishery in order to satisfy the social and economic interests of the coastal state.3. The coastal states' justification is seen in the following:The principle, as it has become established in the draft Law of the Sea, that under certain conditions foreign fishermen should be given access to resources is the result of the interplay of many arguments and considerations, among which biological factors played at most a small part.However, the basic biological argument is apparently straightforward, and is based on a few simple points: (a) It will be assumed that there is a maximum sustainable yield (MSY) which can be taken from any stock, and this yield, and the population level which will produce it can with appropriate research be estimated.(b) This MSY may be modified by economic considerations, as well as by environmental factors.(c) The coastal state shall determine the allowable catch.(d) If this TAC [Total Allowable Catch] is greater than the amount the coastal statecan catch, the difference is a surplus, which can be allocated to foreign fishermen.The most serious difficulty in the simple argument to establish a "surplus" is the implication in the fourth step ((d) above) that if the catch that would be taken by the coastal state, with its existing capacity is (sic) less than the target allowable catch, then the difference-"surplus"--can be taken without affecting the existing coastal state fishery.This is seldom the case.Any fishing by foreign vessels, carried out in addition to fishing on the same stock by the coastal state, will reduce the abundance of the stock.This reduction will tend to reduce the catches by the coastal state, or require it to increase the amount of fishing (and hence costs) if it is to maintain its catch.In either case the benefits to the coastal state from the resources off its coasts will be reduced.The pattern of fishing is therefore on the arguments of the previous paragraphs (sic), sub-optimal, at least to the coastal state.A surplus therefore does not exist.Gulland, Conditions of Access to Fisheries: Some Resource Considerations, in REPORT OF
Source: Ecology law quarterly
DOI: 10.15779/z38mz5x
Author: Burke, William T.
Institution: University of California, Berkeley
Language: English
Subfield: Management, Monitoring, Policy and Law
Field: Environmental Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W758088091
