Work

Reactions to Current Legal Literature

Year: 1966
Type: article
Abstract: Compensation for victims OF VIOLENT CRIME: Not long ago, in the lovely library of the Supreme Court of the United States, my eye caught an interesting article by Dun can Chappell, who is a lecturer in law at the Institute of Criminology in the Sydney University Law School, 167 Phillip Street, Sydney, 2000. It is enti tled Compensating Australian Victims of Violent Crime, and is published in Volume 41, No. 1, of Australian Law Journal. Offprints may be ob tained directly from the author, who at my request prepared this summary of his article : The need to provide schemes to compensate victims of violent crime has been recognized in a number of countries in recent years, including New Zealand, the United Kingdom and certain American states. New South Wales has now become the first Austra lian state to take positive steps to es tablish such a scheme. In this article, the New South Wales, New Zealand and United Kingdom schemes are com pared, and an examination is made of four of the major problems which con front any government which seeks to im plement a crime compensation scheme. (1) Justifying the provision of compensation by the state. United Kingdom and New South Wales schemes have been justified on human itarian rather than legal grounds, com pensation payments being made ex gra tia. In New Zealand the state has ac cepted that it is liable for this type of injury and compensation is made as of right. (2) Eligibility for compensation ?which crimes? In New Zealand twenty-seven crimes of violence are listed to which the relevant legislation applies. In the United Kingdom there is no such list, applications being ac cepted under the scheme in cases where the victim suffered personal injury di rectly attributable to a criminal of fence, or in a law enforcement situa tion. legislation establishing the New South Wales scheme envisages the payment of compensation only for in juries received from an offense which is the subject of criminal proceedings. To avoid what would otherwise be a very serious weakness in the scheme, it has now been announced that the pre rogative powers will be used to make compensation payments to victims of unsolved crimes as well as those which
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W788902248
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10