Year: 2000
Type: article
Abstract: This essay considers the legacy of Kant's philosophy of religion as appropriated by Jacques Derrida in his recent, "Foi et savoir: les deux sources de la 'religion' aux limites de la simple raison."Derrida's adoption of this Kantian framework raises the question of how one might describe this as a postmodern account of religion, which in turn raises the question of the relationship between modernity and postmodernity in general, and Derrida's relationship to Kant in particular.Following an exposition of Derrida's notion of a formal "ethical" religion as a repetition of Kant's critique in Religion Within the Limits of Reason Alone, I offer a critique of Derrida's (and Kant's) "formalization" of religion and the relationship between faith and reason, arguing that a more persistent postmodernism requires a de-formalization of the modern concern for justice, appreciating its determinate prophetic origin.Could it be that deconstruction-offspring of enfant terrible, Jacques Derrida-is in fact only a new attempt to liberate humanity from its selfincurred tutelage?In other words, is deconstruction simply a new Enlightenment, a project we can trace to Kant?And conversely, could it be that Kant was (unwittingly) engaged in deconstruction?Derrida himself seems to hint at just such a genealogy, suggesting something of a German origin of this French movement: "I am resolutely in favor," he proclaims, "of a new university Enlightenment [Aufkliirungl."lAnd more recently, expressly evoking the Kantian tradition of critique, he has undertaken the task of considering religion "within the limits of reason alone"-a "religion without religion"2 which, in the spirit of Kant's "reflective faith,'" would constitute a "universal" religion.4 For Derrida, like Kant, such a religion is ultimately a matter of ethics or justice, such that the "religion" which Derrida discloses is remarkably similar to Kant's "moral religion," including the tie which binds it to democracy.'Further, this plays itself out within a framework which understands the relationship between faith and knowledge in a manner we might describe as "hyper-Kanhan," faulting even Kant for failing to radically think religion within the limits of reason alone-for not being enlightened enough (FS 19/11).Thus Derrida, the consummate "postmodernist," lays claim to a filiation which is distinctly modern, making deconstruction a child of the Enlightenment.Derrida's appropriation of Kant when reflecting on religion, along with
Source: Faith and Philosophy
Authors: James K. A. Smith, The Society of Christian Philosophers
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W791106260
