Work

An Interpretation of Religion: Human Responses to the Transcendent

Year: 1992
Type: book-review
Abstract: Hick's Gifford lectures bring together his reflections on religious epistemology and religious pluralism.Their publication provides an excellent opportunity for reassessing the thought of a philosopher who has made major contributions to the discussion of both issues.Part One contends that "the great world faiths" affirm that the possibility of salvation/liberation "is grounded in reality."Part Two argues that "the universe is religiously ambiguous in that it is possible to interpret it...both religiously and naturalistically."(12) Part Three is epistemological.Hick rehearses his case for claiming that "all conscious experiencing is experiencing-as," and that there are three primary "levels of interpretation ... physical, ethical and religious."Our cognitive freedom is greatest at the third level."It is rationally appropriate," however, "for those who experience their life in relation to the transcendent to trust their own experience, together with that of the stream of religious life in which they participate."(12)(13) Part Four raises the question of religious pluralism.Hick distinguishes between the "Real-in-itself and the Real as humanly thought and experienced," and argues that all "experience of the transcendent is structured either by the concept of deity ... or by the concept of the absolute."These in tum are "schematized in actual human experience" to produce the diversity of "divine personae" and "metaphysical impersonae.""The function of religion in each case," however, is to transform "human existence from self-centredness to Reality-centredness." ( 14)The fifth and final part is criteriological.Hick argues that "the basic criterion is soteriological; and the salvific transformation is most readily observed by its moral fruits, which can be identified by means of the ethical ideal, common to all the great traditions of agape/karuna (love/compassion)."(14) When we apply this criterion, however, we find that the major religions are equally successful in meeting it.There are no "impartial grounds," then, for ranking one religion more highly than another.(3) This is a thoughtful and stimulating book.It is also problematic.I will 259
Authors: William Wainwright, The Society of Christian Philosophers
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W86803479
Cites:
Cited by: 9
Related to: 10