Year: 2014
Type: article
Abstract: Modern disaster planning has taken on increased importance and urgency in light of recent dramatic increase in natural and man-made that resulted in enormous human and economic losses.1 Such planning is aided by examining historical role of nurses in disaster responses. Nurses occupy vital positions in disaster care because of their unique roles with pa- tients and their experience in such areas as evacuation, triage, physical and psychological care, screening measures, case finding, vaccinations, monitor- ing, and disease surveillance and prevention.What does history tell us about nurses' roles in disasters, particularly their provision of disaster relief during initial response phase? Why is this important for disaster responses? And how can this knowledge enhance our understandings of notion of phenomena? For this discus- sion, disaster is defined as a social disruption resulting from natural causes such as earthquakes and hurricanes, technological causes such as explosions or nuclear accidents, and conflict situations such as wartime.2 Research on term behavior has been a significant feature of disaster stud- ies in sociology, but it has not been examined from standpoint of history of nursing. Sociologists Thomas Drabek and David McEntire argue that emergent phenomena include the appearance of interorganizational networks after disaster which attempt to fulfill important societal functions made evident by an extreme event. These networks are composed of many organizations that work together to resolve demands placed on their community in times of disaster.3 Drabek and McEntire argue that people become more cohesive and unified during situations of collective stress, and they work together. Emergent groups often have no previous knowledge of each other, and they may perform nonregular tasks. Local communities are particularly important at this time; they are first to help themselves.4 Often, these emergent groups are most effective and quickest to respond after a disaster.5A history of nursing can contribute to theoretical discussions of emergent behavior. By taking into account nurses' rich heritage in disaster responses, we can learn about which groups should be included in any organizational coordination during disasters.6 This article features case studies of work of nurses and some physicians situated within a local response and one involving international aid. The aim is to enhance understanding of social and po- litical forces that informed nurses' actions and tensions and inconsistences that occurred at particular times in particular places.Doing disaster research has its challenges because records can be lost or destroyed. Some sources are available, however, including newspapers, diaries, letters to family members and other personal correspondence, offi- cial histories from organizations, city records, photographs, and oral sources. Problems include memory loss if a letter was written or an oral history obtained some years later. Yet Joseph Scanlon, who wrote about 1917 Halifax, Nova Scotia, ship explosion, found that disasters are so dramatic that many vividly remember what happened even three-quarters of a century earlier.7Another problem is history is recorded? From whose perspective? A gaping hole includes voices of silenced, including minorities, poor, and others excluded from power. This could be because they may lacked means to document personal experiences, or archivists and librar- ians simply did not seek their stories.8 In my own research, I had to doggedly piece together different sources and read between lines of others to get at silenced voice.In 2010, Arlene Keeling and I edited a book on history of nurs- ing in disasters.9 We concluded, based on 13 case studies, that nurses made crucial independent decisions in crisis situations where time was critical to a person's survival. …
Source: Nursing History Review
Author: Barbra Mann Wall
Institution: University of Pennsylvania
Language: English
Subfield: Emergency Medical Services
Field: Health Professions
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W956440973