Year: 2010
Type: other
Abstract: The final research question is about the context in which the CoPOS was implemented.This is important to practitioners who are looking for prescriptive advice about when CoPs are effective.It is also important to science because it gives insight into factors that affect learning in organizations.This last question is: 5) What contextual factors contribute to the effectiveness of CoPs?The answer to this question can be found in the cross-case analysis at the end of chapter four. Organizing Professional Communities of Practice12 laczuc, 2004;Gorard & Taylor, 2004;Kelly, 2003;McCandliss, Kalchman, & Bryant, 2003;Shavelson, Phillips, Towne, & Feuer, 2003).In design-based research, existing theory, case-based evidence and knowledge from practice is used in order to come to a solution concept (van Aken, 2004) which can be used as a template in order to help solve a field problem.In the case of this research, the field problem considers stimulating organizational development through employee learning.The solution concept will be a set of design principles used for organizing CoPs.In a dialectic between theory and practice (Denyer et al., 2008;van Burg, Romme, Gilsing, & Reymen, 2008), knowledge is built around the context in which generative mechanisms (sometimes known as causal mechanisms) can be facilitated so the desired outcomes are reached (van Aken, 2004).I consider that a generative mechanism is "…a cause that affects outcomes in similar ways across diverse contexts" (Mahoney, 2003, p.4).But, because these causes are contingent (Pawson, 2002), knowledge must be developed about the conditions under which the mechanisms produce desired results, and just as importantly, when they do not.An example of this from the research is as follows: shared understanding is a generative mechanism for group learning.The goal is not to try and establish causality between shared understanding and collective learning, but to understand the conditions under which shared understanding is triggered in order to construct this context so that group learning can occur.In terms of social research, I am looking to explain what makes the 'black box' work during an intervention, not establish the link to an outcome of it.The interventions that comprise the design for stimulating CoPs have been gathered from existing cases, especially those done in cooperation with the Digital University.Each one is grounded in both theory and case evidence from literature as well as case studies done during the research.The complete concept solution (a CoP) is tested using a quasi-experimental design (Cook & Campbell, 1979).Once the concept solution is tested, the results are studied and any possible improvements to the design are made.Then the cycle starts again.The cyclical process of design-based research is illustrated in Figure 1 .2(Andriessen, 2004;Gorard & Taylor, 2004).How to get the incubator filled in with the most promising ventures How to improve my skills so I can improve others' skills?How do I find enough experts willing to help?How do we get stakeholders involved to get the right conditions in place?How can we improve our external connections?How to stimulate others in their entrepreneurial behavior?How can I keep the energy level up in a group? Figure 9.1.Example of a learning agenda and selected items
Author: Donald Ropes
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: professional communities of practice, organizational learning, contextual factors, generative mechanisms, mutual understanding, group learning, collective learning, workplace learning, organizational development, design principles, knowledge management, knowledge sharing, knowledge management systems, knowledge management culture, knowledge management leadership
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W1893975023
