Work

Chronic respiratory questionnaire.

Year: 1994
Type: article
Abstract: REPLY DrThurlbeck objects to our conclusion that the severity of the lesions of the bronchioles and parenchyma assessed by grading techniques in resected lung specimens do not correlate with lung function measurements obtained in the same subjects.We agree that this conclusion is at variance with much that is in the literature and, indeed, re- ported it for that reason.The data we pre- sented make two basic points: (1) that rather extensive emphysematous destruction of the lung can be present in patients who have a normal FEVI, and (2) that a reduction in FEV, did not correlate with increased inflammatory changes in the peripheral airways assessed with current grading systems.This does not mean that we think emphysematous destruction is not important, only that its presence does not explain the decline in FEVI.Similarly, we did not mean to imply that the abnormal peripheral airway function may not eventually be explained by the effects of the inflammatory process in these airways -only that current morphological grading systems do not identify the lesions responsible for the abnormalities in function.We agree with his closing statement that airflow obstruction is a complicated mat- ter in which the different lesions ofthe bronchi (not just chronic bronchitis), bronchioles (not just the Cosio score), and parenchyma (not just emphysema) contribute to the decline in function.Specific responses to the otherpoints raised in his letter follow.The criticism concerning our failure to re- port data on tumour size and stage does not recognise that we have previously reported these data on the first 143 cases entered into our study.'Tumour size, involvement of
Source: Thorax
Author: U Jones
Language: French
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W1964259024
FWCI:
Cites: 49
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10