Year: 2010
Type: article
Abstract: processed in triplicate and verified by sequencing with GAPDH as the internal standard.Expression of mRNA was calculated by the delta threshold cycle.PϽ.05 (2-tailed, Mann-Whitney test), was considered significant.Results.Retinoic acid receptor ␣, RAR, RAR␥, and RAR2,4 amplified in 28 of 28 BCC samples and 22 of 22 SCC samples; RAR1, in 27 of 28 BCCs and 22 of 22 SCC; and RAR1Ј, in 24 of 28 BCC and 2 of 22 SCC.Quantitatively, RAR␣ was 3.46-fold increased (PϽ.001);RAR␥, 1.63-fold increased (P=.001); and RAR1Ј, 23.73fold increased in BCCs compared with SCCs (P = .03)(Figure 1 and Figure 2), but only 2 SCCs showed amplification for RAR1Ј.The findings for RAR, RAR1, and RAR2,4 were indistinct.Comment.Based on the different retinoid sensitivity of BCC and SCC, we expected RAR isoform differences.Interestingly, only 2 of 22 SCCs expressed RAR1Ј at a much lower level than BCCs (9%).In contrast to lung cancer, RAR1Ј does not seem to be pivotal for retinoid chemoprevention in SCC.Levels of RAR␣ and RAR␥ were higher in BCC than in SCC, which fits with reported RAR and retinoid X receptor (RXR) isoform expression. 2 Other factors may mediate chemoprevention.Acitretin binds with low affinity to RARs but with high affinity to cellular retinoic acid binding proteins (CRABPs).Acitretin shifts the distribution of endogenous tretinoin from CRABPs to RAR-RXR heterocomplexes, potentiating its effect.Tazarotene specifically activates RAR and RAR␥ and only weakly activates RAR␣ with chemopreventive effect on BCC in Ptch1± mice. 3 In human lung cancer, RAR4 seems carcinogenic. 4Differential activation of RAR isotypes may therefore have carcinogenic or anticarcinogenic effects as shown by the relative superiority of tazarotene in BCC over other retinoid-related compounds with simultaneous RAR␣ and RAR isoform activation. 3n summary, RAR isoform mRNA expression differs between BCC and SCC.Unlike in lung cancer, the mRNA levels of the recently reported isoform RAR1Ј do not explain SCC retinoid sensitivity.Rather, we assume, the relative sensitivity to retinoid treatment of SCC vs BCC is mediated by differential RAR activation or indirect effects such as shifting endogenous retinoids from CRABPs to RAR-RXR heterocomplexes.
Source: Archives of Dermatology
Authors: J. Scott Henning, Wendi Wohltmann, Chad Hivnor
Language: English
Subfield: Dermatology
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W2033288089
