Developments in predictive displays for discrete and continuous tasks
Year: 1978
Type: dissertation
Abstract: How does one foretell the future?Since earliest times the existence of astrologers, fortune tellers and the like has borne witness to mankind's quest for information about the future.Their methods and the global nature of their predictions are, of course, open to question.But at a more mundane (though none the less important) level, the advent of fast, low-cost, high-capacity digital computers coupled with developments in the art of modelling has meant that computer-based mathematical models of relatively complex systems can be used to provide tentative predictions about the future.Weather forecasting is a case in point.2It will be shown subsequently that Man is fundamentally a predictive, anticipatory creature and that provision of accurate information about the future is necessary for him to cope effectively with his environment.In the field of Engineering, there has been much evidence -admittedly largely from simulation studies of military and vehicular systems -that provision of predictive information in the form of a so-called 'predictive display' facilitates control.However, in spite of the overwhelmingly favourable evidence, there have been few real-world applications, few studies to recommend particular designs of predictive display in specific settings, and few attempts to unify the experimental findings within a common theoretical framework.It is to this gap in our knowledge that the present series of experiments is addressed.The nature of the project has meant that the examples chosen have been restricted to the area of industrial process control.This is not in itself a bad thing: Bainbridge (1972) for example, recommends this field as a fruitful area of psychological study, having problems representative of many other real-world situations.Specifically, this thesis sets out to answer questions such as: 'How do predictive displays based on continuous information differ from those using discrete, non-continuous information?' 'How does varying the parameters of the predictive model affect performance?' studies borne out in the real world?' 'Are the results of laboratory 'Are predictive displays costeffective?' 'How do operators make use of the displays?' 'What are the implications for the ways in which human beings themselves structure information and anticipate consequences?'The plan of the thesis is as follows: The introductory chapters review the literature pertaining to human prediction and predictive control models (Chapter 1), and to engineering aspects of predictive displays (Chapter 2).Chapter 3 describes a fundamental study of predictive display parameters in a laboratory scheduling task, Chapter 4 attempts to verify these findings using test data from an actual job shop scheduling problem.Chapter 5 branches into the area of continuous control with a pilot study.ofpredictive displays in a laboratory simulated continuous stirred-tank chemical reactor.Chapter 6 uses the experience gained in the pilot study as the basis for a coruprehensive study of predictive display parameters in a further laboratory study of a simplified dual-meter monitoring and control task, and Chapter 7 attempts to test the optimal design in a part-simulated semi-batch chemical reactor using real plant and experienced operators in an industrial setting.The results of the experimental programme are summa,ised for convenience in Chapter 8. Chapter 9 draws together the threads from the various experiments and discusses the findings in terms of a general hierarchical model of an operator's control and monitoring behaviour.Finally, Chapter 10 presents conclusions and recommendations from the programme of research, together with suggestions for further work.
Author: Peter J. Goillau
Institution: Loughborough University
Language: English
Subfield: Human Factors and Ergonomics
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W2905562816
