Work

Emotional antecedents of customer loyalty in the formal retail industry of South Africa

Year: 2019
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Despite its substantial growth and contribution to the economy of the country, the \nSouth African retail industry is faced with various challenges, including customers’ \nchanging buying habits and expectations, the evolution of e-commerce, the entry of \ngiant retailers into the retail market, and the growing importance of the urbanised \nmiddle class and its potential purchasing power. \nThis creates risks that are mostly beyond retailers’ control. Therefore, there is a \ngeneral drive among retail brands to build customer loyalty in order to respond to \nthese contemporary dynamics within the industry and, ultimately, enhance \nsustainability. It is noted from literature that current understanding of customer \nbehaviour in the South African retail space is largely the result of rational behavioural \nmeasurement, while the subconscious behaviour of customers is often neglected. \nThe study on which this thesis reports attempted to address this gap in the current \nknowledge base. The current study makes a novel contribution to knowledge in \nusing complementary traditional and neuromarketing instruments in a sequential \nmixed method research design to measure verbal, non-verbal and physiological \nemotions, which indicate the key influential cognitive and emotive factors shaping \nshopping decisions. \nFor a comprehensive understanding of customer behaviour, the study primarily \nexplored the emotional antecedents of customer loyalty in the formal retail industry of \nSouth Africa. In order to explore and describe both retail brands and customers’ \nexperiences regarding the drivers of retail brand loyalty, the empirical phase of the \nstudy adopted a sequential mixed method research design. This design comprised \neight individual semi-structured interviews, which focused on and explored the \nfundamentals of behavioural and attitudinal loyalty within the context of a customer \nrelationship management strategy. \nx \nBased on the findings emerging from the quantitative mall intercept survey with 300 \nretail customers, the study identified the motivating factors of greatest likelihood \namong customers that best explain retail brand loyalty, namely product quality, \nconvenience of location, customer care, product variety and availability, as well as \nfair pricing. Furthermore, findings emerging from the inferential analysis (structural \nequation modelling, two-step cluster analysis, optimal scaling and multivariate binary \nregression analysis) showed that brand trust, brand affect and attitudinal loyalty are \nkey predictors of behavioural loyalty. Additionally, customer loyalty differs depending \non customer predisposition towards the major retail brands tested. In this regard, \nPick n Pay, Massmart and Shoprite/Checkers recorded the most favourable \nperceptions among customers. \nAs Despite its substantial growth and contribution to the economy of the country, the \nSouth African retail industry is faced with various challenges, including customers’ \nchanging buying habits and expectations, the evolution of e-commerce, the entry of \ngiant retailers into the retail market, and the growing importance of the urbanised \nmiddle class and its potential purchasing power. \nThis creates risks that are mostly beyond retailers’ control. Therefore, there is a \ngeneral drive among retail brands to build customer loyalty in order to respond to \nthese contemporary dynamics within the industry and, ultimately, enhance \nsustainability. It is noted from literature that current understanding of customer \nbehaviour in the South African retail space is largely the result of rational behavioural \nmeasurement, while the subconscious behaviour of customers is often neglected. \nThe study on which this thesis reports attempted to address this gap in the current \nknowledge base. The current study makes a novel contribution to knowledge in \nusing complementary traditional and neuromarketing instruments in a sequential \nmixed method research design to measure verbal, non-verbal and physiological \nemotions, which indicate the key influential cognitive and emotive factors shaping \nshopping decisions. \nFor a comprehensive understanding of customer behaviour, the study primarily \nexplored the emotional antecedents of customer loyalty in the formal retail industry of \nSouth Africa. In order to explore and describe both retail brands and customers’ \nexperiences regarding the drivers of retail brand loyalty, the empirical phase of the \nstudy adopted a sequential mixed method research design. This design comprised \neight individual semi-structured interviews, which focused on and explored the \nfundamentals of behavioural and attitudinal loyalty within the context of a customer \nrelationship management strategy. \nx \nBased on the findings emerging from the quantitative mall intercept survey with 300 \nretail customers, the study identified the motivating factors of greatest likelihood \namong customers that best explain retail brand loyalty, namely product quality, \nconvenience of location, customer care, product variety and availability, as well as \nfair pricing. Furthermore, findings emerging from the inferential analysis (structural \nequation modelling, two-step cluster analysis, optimal scaling and multivariate binary \nregression analysis) showed that brand trust, brand affect and attitudinal loyalty are \nkey predictors of behavioural loyalty. Additionally, customer loyalty differs depending \non customer predisposition towards the major retail brands tested. In this regard, \nPick n Pay, Massmart and Shoprite/Checkers recorded the most favourable \nperceptions among customers. \nAs a complement to the quantitative research phase of the study, a Self-Assessment \nManikin attitude measure was applied to a sample of 120 customers. This phase of \nthe study highlighted pertinent emotional elements as key mediators in securing \nsustainable retail brand loyalty. In this regard, Woolworths and Pick n Pay recorded \nthe most favourable perceptions on four stimuli, namely quality, customer rewards, \ncustomer care and brand logos. The study also applied eye tracking and galvanic skin response techniques to a \nsample of 10 participants to determine customers’ psychophysiological reaction to \nthe four stimuli. Galvanic skin response findings showed that customers were \nespecially engaged with Spar, Shoprite/Checkers and Pick n Pay, while eye tracking \nfindings showed customers’ higher visual engagement with Shoprite/Checkers, Pick \nn Pay and Spar. \nA key overall finding of this study was the significant role of feelings and emotions in \ndriving customer loyalty. Retail brands lose relevance when they fail to connect \nemotionally with customers, and without that emotional attachment, brands can \neasily be replaced by generic imposters. A comprehensive understanding of \ncustomer behaviour remains a quandary for marketing and business practitioners. In \nan attempt to address this limitation, the current study used insights from non-verbal \nattitudinal and psychophysiological measures to obtain a more comprehensive \nbehavioural understanding of retail customers.
Language: English
Subfield: Marketing
Open Access status: green
Funder: Strong
OpenAlex ID: W2982974483
Cites: 530
Cited by: 4
Related to: 9