Exploring Latent Profiles of Writing in Linguistically Diverse Students in the Middle School Grades
Year: 2021
Type: dissertation
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: This thesis consists of two studies that investigate longitudinally narrative writing development and factors that lead to low performance in writing in the middle school grades with native English speakers (EL1) and English Learners. The first study consists of two parts. Part A examined writing profiles in Grade 4 and 6 and the resulting relationships to reading outcome measures as well as the effect of language status and gender. Three distinct writing profiles were found in Grade 4 and 6 (low performing, average, and strong writers) which corresponded to similar ability levels on the word reading and reading comprehension outcome measures. There was no EL-EL1 effect on the writing profiles, however there was a gender effect showing that boys were more at risk for writing difficulties than girls. Part B investigated the transition patterns of these writing profiles between Grades 4 to 6. The writing profiles were fairly stable across the middle school grades with a high proportion of students remaining in the same latent profile across time (76.4%). Differences were noted in the transition profiles of boys and girls with more boys remaining in the low performing group over time.The second study investigated the contribution of oral language (vocabulary and syntactic skills) to low performing writing status, beyond that of a base set of predictors, that included rapid naming, working memory, and spelling. In Grade 4, both vocabulary and syntactic skills contributed independently to low performing writing status beyond the base measures. By Grade 6, only syntactic skills were found to be a unique predictor of low performing writing status beyond the base measures. Overall, this thesis provides support that distinct and stable writing profiles can be recognized by the middle school grades in EL and EL1 students and offers insight into the characteristics of low performing writers. The implications of these findings for assessment and intervention and directions for future research are discussed.
Source: TSpace (University of Toronto)
Author: Angela Massey-Garrison
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W3153198024
