Designing for high-speed ships
Year: 2007
Type: dissertation
Abstract: Fast patrol boats are high-speed vessels operated by the Royal Norwegian Navy\n(RNoN). These ships are 36,5 meters long, have a beam of 6,2 meters and operate at high speed (32 knots – 16,5 meters per second) in very restricted waters. The fast\npatrol boats are war ships and navigation tasks performed by the crews are different\nfrom those in civilian high-speed craft. A team of five persons navigate the fast patrol\nboats, and navigation is based on traditional means such as visual observations and\npaper charts. The person leading the team is the navigator.\n\nThe ships were built in the late 1970s and upgraded in 2001 when new navigation\nequipment was installed. However, the crews criticized the modern navigation\nequipment for being complex and difficult to use. In 2002, an upgraded fast patrol\nboat collided with a rock during high-speed navigation. The accident resulted only in\nmaterial damage. Following this accident the RNoN acknowledged the need to gather\nknowledge about human factors and design of navigation equipment.\n\nNavigating a fast patrol boat is about operating a complex socio-technical system.\nStrong demands are put on both people and their tools. In order to design usable\nnavigation equipment for these ships, one has to have knowledge about the ships’\ntask, the crew that carry out the navigation, and the contexts in which navigation\ntakes place. To gather such knowledge, this study observed several navigation teams at work and used different approaches to structure and describe the work of\nnavigation teams. \n\nA hierarchical task analysis was conducted in order to describe navigation in accordance with procedures and established best practices. The assignment navigate to destination was the highest level of the navigator’s work. The assignment included the navigation tasks; plan, start, monitor, change course, and arrive. For each navigation task, a detailed analysis was conducted. It was found that the crews used work practices that emphasize efficiency rather than accuracy in e.g. position fixing. Although efficiency was given priority, the navigation teams controlled system\nvariation in order to keep the ship within safe waters.\n\nA usability study was conducted. This study treated navigation equipment that had\nbeen fitted when the ship was upgraded. A cognitive walkthrough was conducted in\norder to evaluate whether human factors guidelines were applied in the design of the\nmodern navigation equipment. In total 30 usability findings were described. The\nstudy suggested that navigation equipment to little extent were user-centered. The\nnavigation teams compensated for lack of usability by expanding actions and by\nmodifying the equipment.\n\nThe framework of distributed cognition was used to describe the observed work of\nthe navigation teams. Distributed cognition suggests that cognitive processes are not\nbounded by the individual person, but are distributed between humans and the\nphysical artifacts they use. Humans and artifacts that participate in goal directed\nprocesses are said to be in a functional relationship. Within the functional\nrelationships information trajectories describe how information is gathered, shared\nand used. Functional relationships are not static but can configure depending on the\ncontext. In studies of distributed cognitive processes, investigating physical\nrepresentations are important as these are outside the head of the people, yet within\nthe cognitive system.\n\nThe navigation team and their artifacts were described as one cognitive system where the crew and their tools were functionally related. Navigation was in most cases founded on a detailed plan. The navigator drew lines and symbols in nautical paper charts in order to represent the plan. The navigation plan was a resource for the teams’ actions and the charts were a frame of reference for the teamwork on the\nbridge. The crew enriched their tools in order to improve communication and information retrieving. For instance, information important to navigation was to large\nextent noted in the chart. Another example was equipping the bearing device with\nsmall pins in order to feel the direction of the device. Artifacts were also used to\nsupport the navigators’ memory. Pointing the bearing device in the direction of the\nupcoming course meant that the navigator did not have to remember the sailing\ndirection. The dynamic properties of the system did on the one hand provide barriers\ntowards erroneous actions. The crewmembers monitored each other’s tasks and\ncorrected mistakes when necessary. On the other hand, when the functional\nrelationship was not held together, the result was entropy.\n\nThe framework of activity theory was used to provide further descriptions of the\nnavigation teams’ work. Activity theory focuses on people working in a context. In\nthis study, activity was regarded as situated actions taking place in shorter time\nframes. Activity theory claims that the elements of the activity encompass the persons and their use of tools towards a conscious goal. Further, the goals of the activity are influenced by the outcome of the activity and by specific constraints.\n\nActivity theory describes the structure of navigation at different levels. The basic\nconstraints that influenced the navigation teams were related to the space available to maneuver the ship, and to the conditions for making visual observations.\nCrewmembers’ behavior was not constant, but directed towards different motives\ndepending on the circumstances. The crew usually carried out goal related tasks.\nHowever, in some cases the crew directed their work towards the operations of\nequipment or towards solving problems. The framework of activity theory described\nhow internal and external factors influenced the focus of the teams’ work.\n\nBoth distributed cognition and activity theory findings suggested that the teams\nfrequently used artifacts for purposes beyond their initial scope of design. For\ninstance, bearing devices were used to augment navigators’ memory.\n\nBased on the knowledge gathered from task analysis, the usability study, and from\nthe frameworks of distributed cognition and activity theory, a design study was\ncarried out. Four prototypes were produced in order to explore possible design\nsolutions that could improve the thinking and cooperation for the navigation teams.\nThe prototypes included an automatic steering system, an electronic chart, alarm\npanels, and audio alarms. The prototypes emphasized the use of physical\nrepresentations and perceptually rich interfaces. The interfaces used for instance\nsound, vision, and tacitle feedback.\n\nApplying human factors principles in design suggested several design solutions that\npossibly could improve navigators’ working conditions. However, there is a risk that\nnew design will create opportunities for new types of failures. For this reasons, user\nevaluations were suggested as a necessary part of design development. However, user evaluation was outside the scope of this study.\n\nThis study suggested two outcomes of a design processes. One outcome is the\nimprovement of the design in question. The second outcome is the design seeds, that is concepts and techniques that can be reused in other development settings.\n\nDevelopment on navigation technology is at present an industry with strong\nengineering influence and traditions. This study suggested that a user-centered\napproach should involve engineers and work through the engineers’ domain. It was\nsuggested that a design process for development of navigation equipment would\nbenefit from being multidisciplinary, iterative and utilize user evaluation.
Source: NVA (Nasjonalt vitenarkiv)
Author: Bjarte Knappen Røed
Institution: Norwegian University of Science and Technology
Language: English
Subfield: Human Factors and Ergonomics
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
Funders: RNoNA, Sjøkrigsskolen, U.S. Naval Academy
OpenAlex ID: W391176180
