Framing ethnic inequality in political discourses : the role of authoritarianism in the perceived threat to social cohesion
Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: The French model of integration has traditionally opposed the use of racial categories in the organization of public life. In recent years, however, expressions such as white privilege have emerged as interpretive frameworks for understanding society. We investigated the framing effect of this expression — a cognitive bias whereby people react differently to a message depending on how it is worded — in relation to the heightened threat sensitivity of authoritarian individuals (Osborne et al., 2023; Stenner, 2005). An experimental study was conducted with 363 participants, who were asked to imagine a televised debate between two candidates in a political election, during which one candidate claimed that, in France, either white privilege exists (n = 119), Black and Maghribi individuals face a disadvantage (n = 123), or white privilege does not exist (n = 121). Results confirmed a framing effect: the expressions used elicited varying levels of perceived threat to social cohesion, which in turn increased voting intentions for the speaker's opponent. This mediation was moderated by participants' level of authoritarianism. Specifically, highly authoritarian participants perceived the assertion of white privilege and the assertion of a Black or Maghribi disadvantage as equally threatening, and favored the discourse denying the existence of such privilege. Less authoritarian participants, by contrast, perceived the denial of white privilege as more threatening than the assertion of its existence, which was itself perceived as more threatening than the assertion of a Black or Maghribi disadvantage. These findings raise questions about the use of certain expressions drawn from the scientific literature which, when mobilized in political discourse, may prove counterproductive.
Source: theses.fr (ABES)
Institutions: Université Paris Cité, Université Paris 8
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W4414449050
