Year: 2023
Type: dissertation
Abstract: In the school field, prosocial norms are educated and trained to improve students' prosocial behavior. Prosocial norms refer to norms considered as moral in a society that includes altruism and helping others(Siu et al., 2012). Such prosocial norms are explicitly learned by students, especially through moral subjects. \nOn the other hand, the perception of prosocial norms and the resulting prosocial behavior may appear differently depending on the context of the environment. This is because the context of the developmental environment that children encounter has their own norms and rules, and the role expected of children is also different(Crandell et al., 2011). The ecological system model(Bronfenbrenner, 1979) suggests that the perception and prosocial behavior of prosocial norms may vary depending on the context of the major developmental environment in which children belong. \nMoreover, as the prosocial norm is a message that persuades students, studies on the persuasive power of the message were reviewed. According to the message framing effect theory, positive framing emphasizing positive results when following a message and negative framing emphasizing negative results when not following a message have differential effects in persuasion(Maheswaran & Meyers-Levy, 1990). \nThis study was conducted in the following two ways to identify the present and propose the future of prosocial norm education, to distinguish the context of prosocial norms and to find out appropriate framing methods according to context. \nIn the first study, through textbook analysis, the context and framing method of prosocial norms appeared in elementary school moral textbooks were analyzed. As a result of the analysis, the context of prosocial norms could be divided into family, school, and society. In addition, the most frequent contexts of norms were in the order of home, school, and society. As for the framing method, positive framing was used more than negative in all contexts. These analysis results secured reliability by confirming the intercoder reliability between two elementary education experts and researchers. \nIn the second study, typical prosocial norms covered in textbooks were presented as scenarios in the context of home, school, and society to find out the perceptions of fifth and sixth graders in elementary school. At this time, scenario images with different contexts and framing methods of prosocial norms were presented as videos for each framing group. As for the perception of prosocial norms, variables of recognition of importance, moral emotion, and willingness to act were explored by referring to previous studies. \nThe analysis results of the second study are as follows. First, according to the context of prosocial norms, the framing method had a significant effect on the recognition of importance, moral emotion, and willingness to act. In particular, positive framing was more effective than negative framing in raising recognition of the importance of prosocial norms in school and society. Second, according to the context of prosocial norms, there were significant differences in elementary school students' recognition of importance of prosocial norms, moral emotions, and willingness to act. Specifically, the perception of prosocial norms at home was significantly lower than that of prosocial norms in schools and society. \nThrough these research results, first, it was confirmed that the frequency of exposure in the textbook to the context of prosocial norms was consistent with the actual level of perception of students. Second, it was confirmed that it is effective to use positive framing to raise awareness of the importance of prosocial norms in school and society. Third, it was confirmed that the difference in the effectiveness of positive and negative framing was not statistically significant in the perception of the importance of prosocial norms, moral emotions, and willingness to act at home. Fourth, it was found that it is natural that the perception of norms at home is lower than that of norms in school and society according to the ecological system model. \nIn conclusion, this study has educational implications in that it not only examined the context of prosocial norms to confirm the present of prosocial normative education, but also explored effective framing methods according to context to propose an effective future of normative education.
Author: 유지수
Institution: Seoul National University
Language: Korean
Topic: Values and Moral Education
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7025705901
