Work

Money and Time Scarcity: Implications for Economic Decision Making \n

Year: 2019
Type: article
Abstract: Poverty, as a multidimensional concept, includes economic and political elements, as well as social and psychological components. The study of poverty has received much attention in psychological science and in the study of the cognitive consequences of this condition. Mullainathan and Shafir (2013) defined the concept of scarcity as the perception of not having enough. Several studies have investigated the link between scarcity and cognitive ability, suggesting that scarcity imposes additional burdens on people’s mind, through taxing their attention (Mullainathan & Shafir, 2012, 2013). Supporting these results, Mani, Mullainathan, Shafir, and Zhao (2013) suggested that being poor means facing not only with a shortfall of economic resources but also with a contemporary shortfall of cognitive resources. The poor, in this perspective, are less capable not because of intrinsic traits, but because of the very context of poverty, with its related concerns, imposes load and impedes cognitive capacity. Generally, these cognitive resources deficiencies are common in people living in a state of scarcity, which is not necessarily related to money, but that may encounter time constrain (So & Agrawal, 2008) or physical hunger (Briers, Pandelaere, Dewitte, & Warlop, 2006), indicating a common mindset in those who experience the perception of not having enough resources. \nConsidering the high economic insecurity experienced in many parts of the world and the generalizability of the consequences of the scarcity, the main goal of my dissertation is to determine whether a scarcity mindset is immutable or if it is influenced by contextual factors (e.g. how information is framed). Through three different sets of studies, I investigated how experiencing a condition of scarcity affects individuals’ ability to evaluate resources and their economic decisions. Specifically, in Chapter 2, I reported a set of studies in which I examined the effect of monetary scarcity on the economic decision. I assume that people experiencing a condition of monetary scarcity will be less accurate when making economic decisions and more prone to make, in general, suboptimal and inconvenient decision. While, in Chapter 3, I investigated how the experience of scarcity of money compared to scarcity of time impacts allocation trade-offs between both these two resources. I hypothesized that, as a resource, time (vs. money) would be undervalued, regardless of the type of scarcity people were experiencing. Results from these studies shown that there is a common scarcity mindset that characterizes the perception of not having enough. Interestingly, by investigating the tradeoff between time and money when one of these resources is perceived as scarce, people tend to perceive the relevance of the money rather than time as predominant. \nIn the last set of studies, in Chapter 4, I investigated, through three studies, the effect of economic scarcity on the perception of the real (vs. nominal) value of the money. Based on previous research on the money illusion bias, I hypothesized that people experiencing scarcity should be less able to think in terms of the real value of the money, as compared to people that did not experience scarcity. The results confirmed that participants experiencing a condition of scarcity were more prone to experience the money illusion bias, indicating that those participants were more likely to consider the nominal value of money, instead of its real value. \nIt is relevant to build on and extend a deeper understanding of scarcity, especially because the psychology of scarcity will offer substantial practical implications to individuals, practitioners, and policy-makers. A better understanding of what triggers a scarcity mindset could help prevent its often-detrimental downstream consequences in people daily lives and try to point to effective solutions. \n
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7039802279
FWCI:
Cites: 167
Cited by:
Related to: 10