Work

Background Topic Knowledge as a Possible Moderator of the Testing Effect: an Experimental Investigation

Year: 2024
Type: article
Abstract: A large body of research has established a testing effect: testing of information results in better long-term retention than restudying. Given the relevance of such effects for education, there is interest in the conditions and learner differences that may moderate the utility of testing, like pre-existing knowledge. It is possible that (a) the testing effect is stronger for those who are more novice because testing is so effective that it helps novice learners catch up to expert learners or (b) the testing effect works equally well for everyone because it is so robust that all learners can benefit from it. In two experiments, college students read texts and were tested on them one week later. I orthogonally manipulated study strategy (retrieval practice versus restudying) and availability of background material for a given topic. In Experiment 2 only, feedback availability was orthogonally manipulated during testing. I found that participants had significantly better retention when they studied via retrieval practice and received feedback (Experiment 2). This demonstrates that immediate feedback is beneficial for learners, at least over a one-week retention interval. Further, when collapsing across categories of feedback, I found that participants had better retention when they received background topic material, regardless of which study strategy was used (Experiment 2) or performed significantly better when studying via restudying (Experiment 1). These results suggest that the learning benefits of testing do not depend on having high levels of existing domain knowledge.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7045423008
FWCI:
Cites: 73
Cited by:
Related to: 10