Work

Using Revision Prompts to Facilitate Knowledge Creation in Threaded Discussions: An Action Research Study

Year: 2025
Type: dissertation
Abstract: A persistent issue in educational threaded discussions is the shallow interaction among students, who often build only positively on each other’s viewpoints without exploring and resolving differences in understanding. To address this problem, this study proposed using revision prompts to foster knowledge creation and explored the additional approaches to support this process. Revision prompts are explicit instructions encouraging students to revise their original ideas or first notes considering peers’ contradictory perspectives. Knowledge creation is a new learning environment design expecting every student to generate a thirdness that reconciles these contradictions creatively. By investigating the additional strategies needed to facilitate such creative revisions, the study aimed to engage students in creating knowledge in public, thereby promoting internalization or knowledge construction and making their interaction fruitful. Employing a mixed-method action research methodology, this study was conducted over eight weeks in a Moodle-based writing course with ten Mandarin-speaking English learners. Data from journal entries, interviews, and quantitative analyses highlighted the importance of incorporating three additional strategies, including posing one divergent discussion question, offering a participation guideline specifying when and how to post first notes, replies, and revisions, and providing training in deep explanation and design thinking skills. These methods reduced students’ confusion about the new learning design, enabling them to participate more critically, collaboratively, and efficiently. Additional strategies, such as content-specific support to help students transcend their arguments and explanations on the relevance of knowledge creation to their immediate learning objectives, were also implemented. But they showed mixed effectiveness due to the difficulty for students to move beyond justification-mode thinking independently. As a result, most participants struggled to achieve thirdness despite their increased involvement in critical conversations, underscoring the need for a more nuanced approach to promote creative forum participation. This study extends Knowledge Building through a collaborative learning environment design that intentionally facilitates knowledge construction through transformation. It further repositions everyone’s engagement in this transformative process as the catalyst for community progress. Accordingly, it supports all students in developing the capabilities required for such learning, contributing to their ongoing, expansive development in the subject field and participation in a democratic, innovation-driven society.
Author: Xiao, Weiyi
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7132960037
Cites: 204
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10