Year One Hundred Refoundation: a Didactic Proposal for a Cultural Understanding of Quantum Mechanics
Year: 2024
Type: dissertation
Abstract: A. Thomson's model considered the atom as a plum pudding, in which positive and negative charges were mixed together.Some students mixed up ideas coming from different models: 10% of them described Thomson's atom as a planetary model, and 3% of them stated that it had a nucleus with protons and neutrons.For example:A. It had a positive nucleus and electrons rotating around it.A. It had a positive nucleus made of protons and neutrons, and elliptical orbits on which electrons rotated.A. Definitely the conservation of energy.Probably also momentum, but I do not know why.On the other hand, 72% of students used both the conservation laws for explaining the Compton effect.It is interesting to note how, for many students, the photoelectric effect and the Compton effect are seen as two completely distinct phenomena: in the photoelectric effect the photon is in fact "absorbed" by the electron (43%), while in the Compton effect the electron is "bumped and pushed away" by the photon (49%).17% of students recalled the fact that, dealing with photons, the relativistic formulas must be used, while 21% of them highlighted that the photon must be considered as a small material body.A. The photons, colliding with the electrons, behave like small material bodies, and for this reason both momentum and energy are conserved in the collision. Moreover, several students (51%) referred to the quantization of energy:A. In the photoelectric effect and in the Compton effect, Planck's hypothesis and the conservation of momentum and energy are used.No students described the two effects as the same phenomenon, at different energy values.Teachers' answers 22% of teachers used both the conservations laws for the photoelectric effect, compared to 88% for the Compton effect, in line with the percentages related to textbooks.Only 9% of teachers focused on the difference in energy between the two phenomena:A. The principle of conservation of energy and momentum are requested in both (as in all elastic collisions).The only difference is the energy involved in the two phenomena.A. The energy involved in the Compton effect is higher than the one involved in the photoelectric effect.Only 4 people recalled the aspects related to the three-bodies problem:A. Considering both the conservation of energy and the conservation of momentum, it turns out, at some point, that the equations are incompatible unless the energy is zero (there would be no interaction!).And this is because we have three bodies and not two: namely, the photon, the electron, and the metal.In addition to this, 15% of teachers mentioned the quantisation of energy:A. For both the phenomena, the quantisation of energy introduced by Planck is required.
Authors: Giliberti, M.A.L., Mennella, A., Lovisetti, L.
Institution: University of Milan
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: quantum mechanics education, student misconceptions, Compton effect, photoelectric effect, energy-momentum conservation, electron-photon interaction, conservation laws, three-body problem, didactic proposal, teacher misconceptions, history of atomic models, planetary model of the atom, energy quantization
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7155124349
