Correction: Cultivating intention to pursue health-related studies among a pilot group of high schoolers
Year: 2026
Type: erratum
Abstract: The National Research Council assessment of the causes of minority population's lack of participation in science related careers are in part, the following: (1) preschool and early education programs lack focus on reading readiness, early mathematics skills, and concepts of creativity and discovery; (2) K-12 mathematics and science education for underrepresented minorities need improvements; (3) the preparation and retention of mathematics and science teachers is lacking; (4) underrepresented minorities don't have the information, counseling, and outreach about career pathways in science and engineering ; (5) there is not adequate financial support to underrepresented minority students pursuing undergraduate and graduate STEM degrees; among others.(1) The report's authors unequivocally agree that little of the science education research uses students' diversity as a resource in science teaching and learning. (2,3) Diverse students' interests, home languages, ancestry can indeed act as an ignition to promote a pathway from pre-k to university. (4,5) Furthermore, authors recommend teachers use students' histories as a strength and link those to examples and case studies in science projects and students' assignments. These strategies have the greatest potential to engage and retain students in science-related programs and initiatives, and create "smart science people." (6)(7)(8) An example of applying this strategy is to describe a community's health burden and turn it into a class exercise. For instance, in this study students in New York City are assigned to do a sleep log of the past week, and discuss in groups their differences in mood if they had more or less sleep. This assignment is given after students are presented with the fact that close to 40% of New Yorkers suffer from sleep deprivation. (9) On the other hand, teacher education is key to promoting minority students in science-related fields. (4) Research is inconclusive about how rigorous and clinical teacher education needs to be, and provides no evidence that education majors are significantly more productive as teachers than nonmajors. (10) Some recommendations point toward strategies, policies, and practices that conduct community outreach to foster high schoolers' curiosity.( 4) For example, it may be a great opportunity to use community health data as a tool to train teachers of all subjects in health topics and infuse health in every subject.New York City's (NYCs) school district is the largest in the nation. It includes 533 high schools across all five boroughs (Bronx, Queens, Manhattan, Brooklyn and Staten Island). (11) The Bronx (one of four NYC boroughs) is home to 109 high schools and serves 40,047 students. ( 12) The Bronx's school district includes an array of public high schools, which include specialized settings within its geographic districts that focus on specialized topics of instruction, such as science, arts and performing arts, and health professions. (11) Bronx residents experience high rates of poverty, homelessness, barriers to access to health care services, and low educational attainment (13,14), and 90% of the population in the Bronx is of a minority population. (15) New York States (NYS) population is comprised of nearly 20 million people, and from this, 18.8% are of the Hispanic/Latino group followed by 14.3% non-Hispanic Black and 8.2% Asian individuals. Of the nearly 20 million people in NYS, 40% reside in NYC (16) The Bronx is home to 16% of the NYC population.The NYS Board of Regents approved regulations recognize the importance of engaging students' interests in rigorous and relevant academic programs in the Arts; Languages other than English (LOTE)/ Bi-literacy; Career and Technical Education (CTE); Humanities; Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM); and Career Developmental Occupational Studies (CDOS). (17) The 2022-2023 Bronx graduation analyses revealed that less than 1% of Bronx high school students are on the pathway to careers in science, regardless of race, ethnicity, economic status, or English proficiency. (18)The goal of this project is to increase the number of Bronx high school students who pursue studies and careers in health sciences by engaging students in transformative learning experiences to further understand Bronx's health disparities. The research approach is place-based education. The principles of this approach include: (a) reflection, critical analysis, and synthesis of the learning experience; (b) student accountability for learning; (c) active engagement; (d) deeper understanding of self and self in relationship to others; and (e) opportunities for growth throughout. (19)(20)(21). An approach to operationalizing these principles is to enhance class subject unit plans. For example, creating student activities that promote critical analyses and allow the students to insert themself, family, or school experience for reflection to propose a community engagement proposal.The basis of community-based participatory research is that health scientists have a connection and repertoire with their communities, and this is critical to address the community's health needs and achieve meaningful solutions that are sustainable. (22,23) Furthermore, better knowledge of health disparities may increase attitudes, intent, and motivation in health sciences and, in the end, the workforce and their health equity approach to health care. (24) Some of the health outcomes and disparities of interest for adolescents and young adults in the Bronx are related to chronic diseases, reproductive health, mental health, and sleep. (12) For the purposes of this project, the following health topics serve only as entry points for operationalizing the methodological approach and are not necessarily the intervention's sole focus. Scientific evidence on this includes: poor or insufficient sleep is associated with adverse physical and mental health outcomes, (25-27) Among adolescents, insufficient sleep is associated with reduced cognitive function, risk-taking behaviors, and low academic performance. (28,29) Furthermore, insufficient sleep in adolescents is significantly linked to depression, suicidality, and hopelessness. (30) Other evidence indicates that an increase in depression and anxiety among adolescents is due to the use of social media as well as social isolation, partially exacerbated by the COVID-19 lockdowns in this group. (31)(32)(33) Risk-taking behaviors among adolescents are associated with higher rates of sexually transmitted diseases (STDs). Furthermore, among adolescents, the rates of chlamydia, gonorrhea, and syphilis have increased by 3.9%, 4.6%, and 28.6%, respectively. (34) Another growing concern is the increasing rate of type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) among adolescents, particularly among those who identify as Hispanic/Latino and non-Hispanic Black. (35)(36)(37)(38)(39) The purpose of this study was to assess the relation between perceptions, attitudes and readiness to seek a career in health sciences, and their general knowledge of the etiology of the following five health topics: sleep health, STD/human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), T2DM, adolescent mental health, and community health and health disparities, among of a pilot group of senior high school students in the Bronx, NY. This combined knowledge is the baseline for targeting a pedagogical intervention to increase higher education enrollment in the health sciences and related careers.This study was conducted at a public high school in the Bronx, NYC. This high school was selected based on two criteria: 1) the high school is dedicated to preparing students for careers in health-related fields; 2) proximity to the university, which in turn eliminates many barriers to participating in the project's activities. Furthermore, to maintain anonymity and provide de-identified data, the study site will be referred to as The High School (THS) in this article. THS has been open for more than 20 years and serves approximately 350 students in the 9th-12th grades. THS is a Future Ready NYC public school, which means that students have the opportunity to receive all five elements of our Diagnostic Medicine program, which include: Work-Based Learning Opportunities; College-Career Instruction; Early College Credits; Personal Advising and Financial Literacy courses. ( 40)THS students' questionnaire on attitude toward science studies and career intention was a compilation of the following instruments: Science ability developed by La Force 2017 (41,42); Attitude toward Science studies: developed by Germann et al. (43) and Adapted Health Sciences career Intention: developed by La Force, 2016 (44). All components of the survey were uploaded to the SurveyMonkey platform. The items in the survey are presented in Table 2. Each item was measured on a 6-point Likert scale anchored by strongly disagree and strongly agree.A list of the following health professionals were presented to students to rank as their current or potential interest: Audiologist, Chiropractor, Dental Hygienist, Dentist, Massage Therapist, Medical or Clinical Laboratory, Technician, Mental Health counselor, Nurse, Occupational Therapy Assistant, Paramedic, Pharmacist, Pharmacy Technician, Phlebotomist, Physical Therapist, Physician, Physician Assistant, Radiation Therapist, Radiologic Technologist, Respiratory Therapist, Speech-language Pathologist, and Surgical Technologist. This list is a compilation of the most common health professions in NYS. See Graph 1a-1b for all ranked health careers and professions.To assess each student's overall knowledge of sleep health, STD/HIV. T2DM, adolescent mental health, and community health and health disparities. 12 true and false statements were presented and scored. The questions that measured knowledge were developed by subject-matter experts in each health topic, who prepared training modules for teachers in that topic. See Table 3 for the individual questions. Additional covariates include: race/ethnicity (Asian, Black, Hispanic/Latino, Other, White) and gender (male, female).IRB approval was attained as research with minimal risk and was exempt from written consent under protocol number 2025-0400 for CUNY HRRP. Only seniors in the 2025 THS class were invited to participate. THS's auditorium was used for the data collection. Students who consented received a QR code in a handout and completed the SurveyMonkey questionnaire using their smartphones. Students received a $25 gift card for completing the online questionnaire.All collected data were downloaded and processed using Microsoft Excel. Contingency tables were computed to report percentages of students' attitudes toward science studies and career intentions using a scale from strongly disagree to strongly agree. The health professions with the most responses were ranked by current and future interest. Professions with the highest number of responses were ranked by summing frequencies. Finally, knowledge on the five health topics was assessed in a quiz format. The results represent the percentage of students who answered each question correctly. Statistical significance was estimated at P<0.05 to detect differences between Hispanic and non-Hispanic students.A total of 35 seniors from THS completed the questionnaire, representing 70% of the 2025 graduating class. The socio-demographic description of the sample is presented in Table 1.Overall, most of the sample was Hispanic, 171 females between 17 and 18 years of age. 172Non-Hispanic students represented 34% of 173 the sample. There were no significant 174 differences between the Hispanic and non-175 Hispanic students. 176The results from this study are presented in 177 three sections. The first section will describe 178 students' perceptions, attitudes, and 179 readiness to seek a career in health 180 sciences, followed by a second section that 181 will describe students' ranking of current 182 and future health career interests. Finally, 183 section 3 presents the findings on the 184 assessment questions regarding students' 185 general knowledge of the five health topics. 186 187See table 2 for questions gathering students' perception of their ability and attitude toward science and intention of a health science career. All 35 students in the sample completed all questions. Overall, the results indicate that 65% of the students ranked their attitude toward science and their intention of a health science as strongly agree and agree, while more than 50% of the students expressed a feeling of uncertainty, disagreeing, or strongly disagreeing with being better at health sciences than others. In the assessment of attitudes toward science, approximately 11.43 % of the senior class strongly disagree with finding health sciences interesting, and 11.43% disagreeing to that same statement. In total, 22.86% of the senior class does not have a positive attitude toward science. The same pattern was found for the statement: I want to learn more about health science.Neither agree nor disagree was selected in the highest frequency for the question: I'm better at health science than most of the other kids at my school, with 40% of students selecting this answer. In the same token, 31.43% of students neither agree nor disagree with the statement whether they are very good in science or health sciences. Students were asked to rank the health professions career that appealed to them the most. Students were allowed to make multiple selections. Overwhelmingly, the highest ranked careers were in medicine and nursing, 20 responses (57% of responses) and 17 responses (49% of responses) respectively, as shown in Graph 1a.However, students also expressed interests in other health professions such as radiologic technologists, physical therapists, and physician assistants. A complete list of the student's interests in the specific health profession is in Graph 1b.Overall knowledge in sleep health, STD/HIV, T2DM, adolescent mental health, and community health and health disparities.Students were presented with true and false statements to assess their overall knowledge of the five health topics assessed in this investigation. Table 3 indicates the percentage of students who responded correctly to each of the statements.Of all the health topics, the students showed the least knowledge in community health and health disparities, with an average of 32%. The second topic students lacked knowledge on was sleep health and STD/HIV, with both only having a 46% average. Most students knew the most about adolescent mental health, with 78% average. Results from this pilot study point to many learning opportunities for STEM and health sciences among Bronx high school students. This study focused on describing students' perception of their ability and attitude toward science and intention of a health career based on a one-time data collection. Overall, their attitude toward science and their intent toward a health career was high, with most of the participants answering strongly agree or agree to these scales; their perception of their ability in science is less conclusive.According to student replies, about 65% of the sample anticipate taking health classes in college, and 77% of students would like to pursue a profession in health, while 74% of them think the health sciences are exciting. Even so, these results suggest a preference for a health professions career.Students' attitudes about science and their ambition to pursue a career in health are codependent. Of the students in the sample, between 65% and 70% expressed a positive attitude toward science, whereas between 30% and 35% expressed a lack of enthusiasm. Additionally, over 42% of students were unsure if they were exceptionally skilled in the health or scientific areas. There was a significant number of students who expressed not being sure about their abilities in the sciences. This result may be related to the overall high school preparation and merits further investigation.Results of the knowledge test on the five health topics confirmed a great opportunity to teach them on these health conditions, on their prevention and management, and on health disparities. Within these topics, the following are of great significance to young adults in the Bronx and can potentially ignite interest and address disparities in their own communities.• Poor sleep quality is more often reported by women than men. (45) Sexual minorities are also more likely to report poor sleep quality compared to their heterosexual counterparts (46). Differences in sleep duration have been observed at the intersection of sexual identity and race/ethnicity. (47) Numerous studies have revealed associations between sleep outcomes and factors of socioeconomic status. (26) • In addition to social and economic inequalities, people who identify as minorities are particularly vulnerable to depression and suicidality. (48) Similarly, compared to the general population, youth who identify as sexual minorities are more likely to experience poor mental health and suicidality. (42) • Physicians are less likely to enroll young people in preventive care, including pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP). Only about 1 in 3 physicians have ever prescribed PrEP, a highly effective HIV prevention medication to this group (49) (2). Although this statistic is encouraging, when it comes to racial and ethnic minority groups (Hispanic/Latino, non-Hispanic Black, and American Indian) and girls, they continue to be low and are underrepresented. (1,55) In particular, non-Hispanic Black high school students have the lowest interest in STEM fields, followed by Hispanic/Latino students (56). There is no specific data collected on high school students' interest in health research or related topics.Although the health care industry is the largest employment sector in the US, there is a significant and growing shortage of physicians (both primary care and specialists) and other healthcare providers and professionals, which is projected to worsen in the coming years. (57,58) With the growing and aging US population, the shortage of healthcare providers is expected to worsen. (59) This situation is further complicated by other factors, such as shortages in the number of individuals entering a healthcare profession, significant disparities in the distribution of healthcare professions, and shortages in underserved areas. (60,61) An assessment of the ethnic/racial diversity of the current healthcare workforce of the following 10 health care professions (advanced practice registered nurses, dentists, occupational therapists (OTs), pharmacists, physical therapists (PTs), physician assistants (PAs), physicians, registered nurses, respiratory therapists (RTs), speech-language pathologists), found that in the U.S. there is a need for programs that seek to increase the ethnic/racial of Black, Hispanic, and American people in the health care professions. Results from this study indicate that high school students are in learning more about the many health professions that are in shortage and are projected to continue to is a pilot study with a sample, the opportunities between Future studies focus on with multiple to the and of the and to assess the of results indicate that students at THS have attitudes and intentions health significant regarding their scientific and in knowledge in the health topics These knowledge may be an opportunity for the project to foster students' interest in each health topic and their research intention on health disparities research in the Furthermore, it the educational which uses students' diversity as a resource in science teaching and this project is to the health care workforce in the to the Health and the Bronx is as a a Health about the causes of the Bronx's shortage is Some research points to a lack of for and due to increasing rates of community in the and having this end, it is to learning opportunities for high school students with in science and health disparities to create a and more of health for students by school indicate the greatest to students in their a and growing health care workforce in science and health disparities will be to to the and needs of a population, to achieve health
Source: Frontiers in Education
Authors: Maria-Isabel Roldós, Judith Aponte
Institutions: Lehman College, City University of New York, Hunter College
Language: English
Subfield: Applied Psychology
Field: Psychology
Domain: Social Sciences
Keywords: underrepresented minority students, high school students, health education, sleep deprivation, community health data, teacher professional development, STEM career pathways, New York City public schools, culturally responsive teaching, student engagement in science, health workforce shortage, health workforce diversity
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,353
Funder: City University of New York
OpenAlex ID: W7167912738
