Work

The Semiotic Barrier of Being (SBB): A Mathematical Demarcation of Life and Chemistry

Type: article
Abstract: This paper introduces the Semiotic Barrier of Being (SBB) — a fundamental thermodynamic and information-theoretic phase threshold positing the strict irreducibility of symbolic (sign) functions to unconstrained prebiotic physicochemical kinetics. The SBB is mathematically formalized as a critical boundary condition at which the sign-value mapping becomes conventional (arbitrary) rather than determined by intrinsic molecular affinities. To operationalize the transition across this barrier, we introduce three quantitative metrics: Indicator semantic entropy (), which formalizes the functional capacity of an internal cybernetic interpreter within the system; Thermodynamic arbitrariness coefficient (), derived from non-equilibrium statistical mechanics to quantify the degree to which a code diverges from baseline stereochemical affinities; Contextual sensitivity coefficient (), which formalizes the dependence of the system’s operational output on structural semiotic history rather than on local chemical configurations. Drawing on a generalized formulation of Landauer’s principle, Kolmogorov algorithmic complexity, and Hopfield’s kinetic proofreading mechanisms, we demonstrate that the metabolic and thermodynamic work required to fix arbitrary semantic information against natural chemical affinities exceeds baseline syntactic polymerization bounds by more than an order of magnitude. To overcome the logical limitation of relying on an external observer as an analytical proxy, we propose an automated, chemically closed Autonomous Energetic SELEX (AE-SELEX) microcompartmental protocol. This provides a concrete, empirically testable architecture capable of either falsifying or corroborating the SBB theorem over finite evolutionary generations. The SBB framework does not deny evolution but establishes the non-equilibrium architectural constraints under which physical systems transition from raw chemical dynamics to rule-governed biosemiotic closure.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7172477884
Cites: 25
Cited by:
Related to: 9