Work

From avoidance to adoption: strategies for integrating AI in higher education contexts

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Introduction This paper aims to identify effective strategies for integrating Artificial Intelligence (AI) in higher education (HE), specifically addressing the challenges related to AI literacy, ethical concerns, and institutional variations. It provides a framework for incorporating an “embracing” approach to AI adoption, characterised by strategic incorporation of AI tools and underpinned by AI literacy and constructive AI skepticism. Methods The paper employs three main approaches. First, we explore current challenges faced by instructors in taking an embracing approach, particularly in relation to AI literacy. Second, we introduce instructor AI skepticism from a multi-layered perspective. Third, we present a series of case studies from universities in Northern Ireland reflecting on challenges of the embracing approach across STEM, Humanities, and Social Sciences, and how these challenges have been addressed. Results An exploration of AI adoption across different subject areas in four case studies demonstrates substantial variability in AI literacy, AI skepticism and acceptance across disciplines. Nonetheless, broader common themes emerge across the case studies. These themes generally involve critical thinking and application of subject area-specific theories to new contexts. Crucially, structured instructional approaches significantly reduce misconceptions and enhance ethical AI usage. Discussion This study uniquely integrates discipline-specific case studies and institutional context analyses. It contributes to understanding AI literacy as a multidimensional skillset. It further positions AI literacy as a critical means of addressing the underrepresented instructors' multilayered AI skepticism, with an emphasis on ethical considerations and critical student engagement. Our recommendations highlight the necessity for targeted faculty training, clear institutional policies, and structured curriculum integration strategies to foster AI literacy, address instructor skepticism, and enhance ethical awareness effectively.
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,353
OpenAlex ID: W7202267311
FWCI:
Cites: 30
Cited by:
Related to: 10