Neurodevelopmental Diversity as Population-Level Cognitive Resilience: Evolutionary Persistence, Environmental Disability and the Case for a More Inclusive Society
Year: 2026
Type: preprint
Abstract: Autism and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) are highly heritable and polygenic. Common variants associated with both conditions are spread across the general population, and the evolutionary record for them is mixed. In single analyses, common autism-associated alleles showed signatures of positive selection, and ADHD-associated alleles appeared to decline in frequency since the Palaeolithic in European samples. These are findings about associated variants, and they leave open whether either condition was itself a target of selection. This paper introduces population-level cognitive resilience: the capacity of a group to perceive, evaluate and respond to information, uncertainty and threat, sustained in part by variation in how its members process information. It proposes that neurodevelopmental diversity may contribute to this capacity under specified environmental conditions, and it sets out five propositions, each paired with the evidence that would count against it. The argument draws on studies reporting reduced susceptibility to framing and other decision biases among autistic participants, and on collective intelligence research reporting that group performance tracks members' social perceptiveness. The paper treats the second body of evidence as a competing prediction and weighs it against psychometric doubts about the test used to measure social perceptiveness. It applies the social and relational models of disability to argue that institutional design decides whether cognitive variation reaches collective decisions. It then connects the argument to cognitive security, where shared heuristics create shared exposure to manipulation. The rights-based case for inclusion stands independently of every proposition in this paper.
Author: Gardner, Sarah
Language: English
Subfield: Cognitive Neuroscience
Field: Neuroscience
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W7229700161
