Ambiguous Consumer Vulnerability: How Transgender Consumers Navigate the Co-Constitution of Agency and Harm
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Consumer vulnerability research treats harm and agency as oppositional: vulnerability arises when restricted access to marketplace resources erodes agency, and restoring agency is assumed to reduce harm. Current research also presumes that vulnerable consumers occupy a stable, if constrained, legal position. Through an ethnography of UK-based transgender consumers, we problematize both assumptions and develop the concept of ambiguous consumer vulnerability: a condition in which harm arises not only when market access is withdrawn and agency is constrained, but also when consumers assert their agency by participating in the marketplace. Because the marketplace is inescapable and central to identity and well-being, exiting is not an option; consumers instead engage in the volitional absorption of harm to maintain market access. We show how this co-constitution of agency and harm is intensified by legal precarity, which renders the ambiguity persistent and unevenly distributed across services. We identify three strategies—circumventing, educating, and conforming—through which consumers navigate, rather than resolve, ambiguous consumer vulnerability, and then explore how legal precarity complicates the efficacy of these navigation strategies. We contribute to service research by reexamining the relationship between vulnerability, agency, and harm, and offer managerial guidance—seamless service inclusion and inconsequential fluidity—for more inclusive services.
Source: Journal of Service Research
Authors: Varala Maraj, Mario Campana, Rohan Venkatraman
Institutions: University of Bath, Deakin University
Language: English
Subfield: Marketing
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $3,900
OpenAlex ID: W7234394652
