Work

Extraneous Cognitive Load as a Bottleneck in Mathematical Problem Solving: The Case of Analytic Geometry

Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This study examined the role of extraneous cognitive load as a bottleneck in mathematical problem solving among undergraduate mathematics students learning Analytic Geometry. Cognitive load theory posits that unnecessary processing demands can deplete working memory resources needed for higher-order problem solving, yet this mechanism has received limited attention in university mathematics education. A within-subject explanatory mixed methods design was employed with 25 mathematics department students who completed equivalent Analytic Geometry problem-solving tasks in two presentation conditions: a conventional format with separated diagrams and redundant information, and a cognitively optimized format featuring integrated representations and reduced extraneous elements. Data were collected through problem-solving tests, perceived cognitive load ratings, time on task, written solution analysis, and semi-structured interviews. The results showed that students achieved higher problem-solving scores in the optimized condition compared to the conventional condition, reported lower extraneous cognitive load, and completed tasks more efficiently. Correlation and regression analyses indicated that extraneous cognitive load was the strongest predictor of performance, with large effect sizes observed for all outcomes. Qualitative findings revealed that students benefited from integrated diagrams, clearer symbolic representation, and reduced information search, while low prior knowledge students were particularly vulnerable to split-attention and redundancy effects. The study concludes that extraneous cognitive load is a critical bottleneck in mathematical problem solving that can be systematically addressed through instructional design without sacrificing mathematical rigor. These findings offer practical implications for designing Analytic Geometry materials and contribute to research on cognitive load theory, mathematical thinking, and educational technology.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W7235311328
FWCI:
Cites: 29
Cited by:
Related to: 10