Arguing for Global Citizenship in higher education teacher training: evaluating a third action research cycle with EFL pre-service teachers
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: This research article evaluates Arguing for Global Citizenship and the 4Rs Framework for Deeper Learning in higher education foreign language teacher training. Both related frameworks represent a comprehensive reconceptualization of commonly used approaches to arguing in Foreign Language Education, highlighting the promotion of Global Citizenship skills, multiperspectivity, and socio-emotional learning, specifically empathy, in the context of deeper learning in the language-as-discipline classroom. This is central for equipping learners with adequate arguing skills in order to respond to and act upon contemporary crises and navigate discourses democratically, constructively, critically, and empathically. However, a comprehensive reconceptualization of arguing practices must also include the preparation of educators to adjust their approaches to teaching arguing as well as corresponding research in FLE contexts, including higher education teacher training. In a third cycle of exploratory action research, this study explores Arguing for Global Citizenship and the 4Rs Framework for Deeper Learning with higher-education EFL pre-service teachers ( N = 41) throughout the course of a semester. The analyses draw on pre- and post-questionnaires assessing understanding of the goal of argumentation as well as a quantitative assessment of competitiveness, actively open-minded thinking, empathy, and compassion towards oneself and others, in addition to the implementation of these frameworks in pre-service teachers’ conceptualizations of teaching arguing through voluntary interviews ( N = 7) and the collaborative development of Deeper Learning Episodes ( N = 9). Findings revealed no significant differences in the quantitatively assessed constructs from pre- to post-test. Arguing goals were diverse across both assessments but became less focused on structure and composition and increasingly constructive, reflective, and more empathic after the seminar. Interviews reflected a closer alignment with Arguing for Global Citizenship and the 4Rs Framework , and Deeper Learning Episodes revealed a partial implementation of both frameworks in pre-service teachers’ practical conceptualizations. The article concludes by discussing implications for further research and for the implementation of Arguing for GC and the 4Rs in higher education teacher training and school contexts.
Source: Frontiers in Education
Institution: Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz
Language: English
Subfield: Language and Linguistics
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
SDG: Quality education
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,353
OpenAlex ID: W7236448404
