Charles Sanders Peirce A NEGLECTED ARGUMENT FOR THE REALITY OF GOD. PART 1 Transl. from English by Nadezhda V. Zudilina
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: God is Ens necessarium, Really (i.e., regardless of whether anybody believes it to be so or not) creator of all three Universes of Experience. Experience is a brutally produced conscious effect that contributes to a habit, controlled by the thinker’s self. There are Three Universes of Experience: the First is of Ideas, the Second is of the Brute Actuality of things and facts. The Third is of Signs. Signs include a living consciousness, the life and power of growth of a plant, a daily newspaper, a great fortune, a social “movement”. An Argument is any process of thought reasonably tending to produce a definite belief. If God Really be, and be benign, then we should naturally expect that there would be some Argument for His Reality that should be obvious to all minds, and that this Argument should present its conclusion in a form directly applicable to the conduct of life, and full of nutrition for man’s highest growth. The Neglected Argument best fulfils this condition. Pure Play is an agreeable occupation of mind which involves no purpose save that of casting aside all serious purpose. It has no purpose, unless recreation. It has no rules, except the law of liberty. It is a lively exercise of one’s powers, which may take either the form of esthetic contemplation, or that of distant castle-building, or that of considering some wonder in one of the Universes, or some connection between two of the three, with speculation concerning its cause. It is this last kind is called “Musement”. In time, it will flower into the “Neglected Argument”. Let religious meditation be allowed to grow up spontaneously out of Pure Play without any breach of continuity, and the Muser will retain the perfect candour proper to Musement. Musement begins passively enough with drinking in the impression of some nook in one of the three Universes. But it soon passes into attentive observation, observation into musing, musing into a lively give-and-take of communion between self and self. Man is able to understand the laws and the causes of some phenomena, therefore any given problem would get rightly solved by man, if a sufficiency of time and attention were devoted to it. With your eyes open, awake to what is about or within you, and open conversation with yourself. It is, however, not a conversation in words alone: like a lecture, it is illustrated with diagrams and with experiments. In the course of Musement, psychological and semi-psychological, and then metaphysical questions would doubtless get touched. Let the Muser begin by pondering them from every point of view, until he seems to read some truth beneath the phenomena. After appreciating the unspeakable variety of each Universe, let the Muser turn to speculations on the homogeneities of each Universe, and then to the consideration of homogeneities and connections between two different Universes, or all three. In them all we find Growth, itself consisting in the homogeneities of small parts. In growth the three Universes conspire, and a universal feature of it is provision for later stages in earlier ones. This is a specimen of certain lines of reflection which will inevitably suggest the hypothesis of God’s Reality. In the Pure Play of Musement the idea of God’s Reality will be sure to be found an attractive fancy, which the Muser will develop in various ways. The more he ponders it, the more it will find response in every part of his mind, for its beauty, for its supplying an ideal of life, and for its thoroughly satisfactory explanation of his whole threefold environment.
Authors: Peirce, Charles, Zudilina, Nadezhda
Institution: V.I. Vernadsky Crimean Federal University
Language: Russian
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W7166554458
