Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Background Online reviews combine star ratings, written evaluations and platform source cues. This study examines the association between rating–text inconsistency and review helpfulness across purchase-verification groups. Methods This observational study uses 479,493 reviews from six Amazon Reviews’23 categories over 2019–2022. A supervised text model was trained on product-disjoint data. Its calibrated test mean absolute error was 0.474 rating points. Helpful-vote counts were modelled using Poisson pseudo-maximum likelihood with product-clustered confidence intervals. Rating indicators, product fixed effects and exploratory specification checks were examined. Results The model-based discrepancy was positively associated with helpful votes in the pooled model (incidence rate ratio = 1.37, 95% confidence interval [1.25, 1.50]). The unverified-review slope was not significant with product and rating fixed effects (incidence rate ratio = 1.025, p = .822). Directional contrasts changed when endpoint ratings were excluded. The verification interaction was negative in the full-sample model ( b = −0.387, p < .001). It was not significant in the product fixed-effects model ( b = 0.117, p = .346). In the two-to-four-star restriction, the pooled M1 association was not statistically significant (IRR = 1.059, p = .067). In the post hoc human-coding diagnostic, model-based and human-implied absolute discrepancies showed limited correspondence (Spearman correlation = 0.234). Conclusions The findings concern a model-based discrepancy measure. Directional patterns and verification moderation depend on the specification and rating range. The human-coding diagnostic indicates limited correspondence with independently coded evaluations. Broader validation is needed before interpreting the measure as perceived inconsistency. The estimates describe observational associations.
Source: F1000Research
Author: NEBİ SEREN
Institution: Bursa Uludağ Üni̇versi̇tesi̇
Language: English
Subfield: Marketing
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $1,350
OpenAlex ID: W7234584630
